No ‘clear evidence’ of Vietnam’s role as trade vehicle for Chinese exports to US: IMF

By Minh Anh
Wed, October 2, 2024 | 3:29 pm GMT+7

The International Monetary Fund has said it found no clear evidence of Vietnam’s role as a one-stop trade vehicle in facilitating Chinese exports to the U.S., amid the idea of Vietnam benefiting from trade tensions between the world’s two largest economies.

Hai Phong port in Hai Phong city, northern Vietnam. Photo courtesy of Hai Phong Maritime Port Authority.

Hai Phong port in Hai Phong city, northern Vietnam. Photo courtesy of Hai Phong Maritime Port Authority.

To test whether Vietnam has been used as a one-stop trade vehicle, i.e., imports from China are repackaged and exported to the U.S. without additional domestic value added, the IMF looked at the backward trade linkage with China in Vietnam’s exports to the U.S., i.e., how much China-originated value added is embedded in Vietnam’s exports to the U.S.

If there was a faster-growing share of China-originated value added in Vietnam’s exports to the U.S. compared to its peers, it would indicate some evidence of a trade vehicle role, said the fund in the conclusions on its 2024 Article IV consultation.

Vietnam’s backward trade integration with China preceded 2018. The share of China-originated value added in Vietnam’s total exports to the U.S. has increased at a faster pace than its ASEAN and OECD emerging market peers since 2000.

However, this backward linkage decelerated during 2018-2022, growing slower than its peers, suggesting no clear evidence of Vietnam serving as a trade vehicle. Vietnam has also taken measures to avoid being used to reroute Chinese goods to the U.S. to circumvent trade barriers, the IMF affirmed.

Notably, ASEAN emerging markets except Vietnam saw their backward linkage with China growing faster since 2021.

At the sectoral level, there is limited evidence of trade rerouting through Vietnam in certain strategic sectors, albeit not broad-based. For example, Vietnam saw an accelerated growth of backward linkages with China in petroleum, chemical, and nonmetallic mineral products since 2021 while, instead, a slower growth than ASEAN peers in electrical and machinery products.

Source: Vietnam: 2024 Article IV consultation, IMF.

Source: Vietnam: 2024 Article IV consultation, IMF.

If Vietnam served as a vehicle country for Chinese exporters to circumvent U.S. tariffs, one would expect similar rising trends in Chinese exports to Vietnam and U.S. imports from Vietnam specifically in strategic sectors affected by tariffs. But sectoral trade flows do not reveal clear evidence of a one-way street.

The fund elaborated that U.S. sourcing of strategic inputs from Vietnam accelerated during 2018-2022 and has stabilized since. The pace of this increase matched the rise in its overall market share in U.S. imports.

But Vietnam’s market share in these strategic sectors has not yet climbed above its overall market share in U.S. imports despite U.S. tariffs on China’s strategic sectors.

Looking at China, the share of Chinese exports to Vietnam in strategic sectors has stabilized since 2020. At the same time, China has increasingly imported strategic goods from Vietnam; its sourcing from Vietnam rose almost threefold from 2% in 2017 to 6% in 2023.

Combining these trends suggests that strategic exports from China to Vietnam cannot merely be attributed to rerouting trade to the U.S, the IMF analysis found.

Instead, China may have been increasingly exporting to Vietnam in strategic sectors as part of Vietnam’s increasing integration into the Chinese supply chain (e.g., China moves production to Vietnam, possibly due to lower labor costs, and imports back for further processing or final demand).

In conclusion, the IMF analysis found that in terms of aggregate and sectoral trade flows, China’s export share to Vietnam and the U.S. import share from Vietnam have increased in lockstep, and so has China’s import share from Vietnam. These trends span also strategic sectors, but only accelerated during 2018-2022, and have ebbed since.

Regarding content of Vietnamese exports, domestic value added in Vietnam’s exports to the U.S. has increased, especially in strategic sectors, while China-originated value added has remained flat in all but some strategic sectors since 2017.

Comments (0)
  • Read More
Vietnam's stock market watchdog suspends two Grant Thornton auditors

Vietnam's stock market watchdog suspends two Grant Thornton auditors

Vietnam's State Securities Commission (SSC) has suspended two auditors from Grant Thornton Vietnam after determining that the 2024 audited financial statements of Saigon Water Infrastructure Corporation (HoSE: SII) failed to meet required standards.

Banking & Finance - Thu, October 16, 2025 | 3:35 pm GMT+7

Law No. 56 a major policy breakthrough for Vietnam's stock market development

Law No. 56 a major policy breakthrough for Vietnam's stock market development

The Law No. 56, effective January 1, 2025, is one of the major legal breakthroughs in recent years that will enhance the transparency and operational efficiency of the Vietnamese stock market.

Finance - Thu, October 16, 2025 | 2:30 pm GMT+7

WHA Group breaks ground on smart technology industrial zone in central Vietnam

WHA Group breaks ground on smart technology industrial zone in central Vietnam

Thailand's WHA Group on Tuesday broke ground on a world-class, modern, and environmentally friendly industrial zone in central Vietnam, namely the WHA Smart Technology Industrial Zone-Thanh Hoa.

Real Estate - Thu, October 16, 2025 | 2:00 pm GMT+7

Vietnam a key partner in Murphy Oil’s global strategy: exec

Vietnam a key partner in Murphy Oil’s global strategy: exec

Vietnam remains a key partner in Murphy Oil’s global business strategy, said Eric Hambly, the U.S. corporation's president and CEO.

Companies - Thu, October 16, 2025 | 12:06 pm GMT+7

VNPT, Qualcomm debut Vietnam’s 1st original design-based excellence center

VNPT, Qualcomm debut Vietnam’s 1st original design-based excellence center

State-owned Vietnam Posts and Telecommunications Group (VNPT) and Qualcomm have officially launched the VNPT-Qualcomm Excellence Center (VQEC), the first facility in the country to operate under an original design co-development model using Qualcomm’s core technologies.

Companies - Thu, October 16, 2025 | 8:41 am GMT+7

Indonesia enjoys steady growth in nine months

Indonesia enjoys steady growth in nine months

Indonesia's Ministry of Finance on Tuesday announced the country’s 2025 budget performance as of September, reporting that Southeast Asia’s largest economy continued to post steady growth despite global economic uncertainties.

Southeast Asia - Wed, October 15, 2025 | 9:53 pm GMT+7

Malaysia on progressive path towards AI nation status: experts

Malaysia on progressive path towards AI nation status: experts

Malaysia is on a progressive track towards becoming an Artificial Intelligence (AI) nation by 2030, a goal seen as achievable under Budget 2026 - the Malaysian Government’s fiscal and policy framework for 2026.

Southeast Asia - Wed, October 15, 2025 | 9:44 pm GMT+7

Thailand steps up development of semiconductor industry

Thailand steps up development of semiconductor industry

Thailand’s Board of Investment (BOI) plans to propose a new national semiconductor and advanced electronics policy board to the government, which will spearhead Thailand’s semiconductor development strategy.

Southeast Asia - Wed, October 15, 2025 | 9:40 pm GMT+7

ASEAN sets ambitious energy targets

ASEAN sets ambitious energy targets

Senior energy officials from ASEAN member nations and Timor-Leste on Tuesday convened in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, to finalize key outcomes and policy recommendations to be submitted to the 43rd ASEAN Ministers on Energy Meeting (AMEM).

Southeast Asia - Wed, October 15, 2025 | 9:33 pm GMT+7

Sun Group gets nod for $375 mln inland waterway tourism project in central Vietnam

Sun Group gets nod for $375 mln inland waterway tourism project in central Vietnam

A subsidiary of Sun Group, one of Vietnam’s leading real estate developers, has received approval to invest VND9.88 trillion ($375 million) in an inland waterway tourism project in the central coastal city of Danang.

Industries - Wed, October 15, 2025 | 5:21 pm GMT+7

Vietnamese luxury car dealer Haxaco’s business slumps, stock nears two-year low

Vietnamese luxury car dealer Haxaco’s business slumps, stock nears two-year low

The operations of Hang Xanh Automobile Service JSC or Haxaco (HoSE: HAX), known as the largest distributor of Mercedes-Benz vehicles in Vietnam, are under pressure as consumers tighten spending and competition among car brands intensifies.

Companies - Wed, October 15, 2025 | 5:13 pm GMT+7

Vietnam sets 2026 GDP growth target at 10%

Vietnam sets 2026 GDP growth target at 10%

The Vietnamese Government has set the targets for economic expansion in 2026 at about 10% and inflation at 4.5%.

Economy - Wed, October 15, 2025 | 4:28 pm GMT+7

Movement of mega projects creates momentum for central Vietnam's Van Phong Economic Zone

Movement of mega projects creates momentum for central Vietnam's Van Phong Economic Zone

A series of large-scale projects in Van Phong Economic Zone are being accelerated, opening new prospects for breakthroughs in this key growth hub of Khanh Hoa province.

Industries - Wed, October 15, 2025 | 12:24 pm GMT+7

Vietnam's International Financial Center ambition can unlock new wave of innovation

Vietnam's International Financial Center ambition can unlock new wave of innovation

By embedding clarity, consistency, and collaboration into the foundations of its International Financian Center, Vietnam can create not just another financial center, but a hub for innovation that connects Asia to the world, writes Phil Wright, COO, HSBC Vietnam.

Consulting - Wed, October 15, 2025 | 11:03 am GMT+7

Gamuda Land expands Singapore portfolio with Chencharu Close win

Gamuda Land expands Singapore portfolio with Chencharu Close win

Gamuda Berhad has announced that its property arm, Gamuda Land, has formally executed the acceptance of the award for a significant land parcel at Chencharu Close, Yishun, Singapore.

Companies - Wed, October 15, 2025 | 10:41 am GMT+7

Duc Giang Chemicals makes progress at $2.2 bln bauxite project in central Vietnam

Duc Giang Chemicals makes progress at $2.2 bln bauxite project in central Vietnam

Duc Giang Chemicals Group (HoSE: DGC) has taken an initial legal step toward developing an integrated bauxite-alumina-aluminum complex project worth VND58 trillion ($2.2 billion) in Lam Dong province.

Industries - Wed, October 15, 2025 | 8:32 am GMT+7