50-70 year apartment ownership certificates 'good for the market'

By Thanh Lam
Sat, June 11, 2022 | 7:00 am GMT+7

The Ministry of Construction’s proposal on granting apartment owners 50-70 year ownership certificates, instead of the current permanent ownership, has stirred public controversy. The Investor talks with David Jackson, CEO of Colliers Vietnam, about the issue.

Do you support the Ministry of Construction's proposal on granting apartment owners a certificate of property use with a definitive term of 50-70 years? And what are the pros and cons if put into practice?

The proposal is good for the market in the long run. The idea is proposed for new apartment projects and does not touch on the existing freehold apartments that owners secure indefinitely.

If the proposal is approved and the amendment of the Law on Housing is made with a reasonable roadmap, adequate alternatives for homeowners when the lease expires, clear laws and regulations, plus proper communication, it would diversify the residential market and open more investment opportunities for homeowners, investors, and developers.

Market prices for leasehold apartments are generally lower than that of a freehold unit in the same areas, though this may not hold true in all cases. Those looking for freehold properties they can pass on to future generations may accept higher prices.

Young people, families with a limited financial budget, or investors interested in rental yields can opt for leasehold apartments at more affordable prices, then move elsewhere later when their needs change. So, offering diversified housing options should be good for the long-term health of the market.

What complex problems will arise from granting apartment owners 50-70 year ownership certificates?

It shall be noted that there are provisions that allow the government to reclaim the land (including land with apartment blocks built on it) for vital infrastructure or security purposes, and this is a fact not only in Vietnam but in other countries too. So, whether an apartment involves a freehold or leasehold would make little difference.

Culturally, for the majority of Vietnamese, house ownership is intrinsically linked to inheritance value. Therefore, a tactful approach in this aspect is key, together with a reasonable roadmap, clear laws and regulations as well as proper communication, as mentioned above.

For homeowners, it should be considered that perception changes over time. People tend to think of a long-term stay and hence prefer freeholds. However, family structures in Vietnam, especially in urban areas have changed in the past decades, and there are now more young people living in apartments.

Across the world, land is a limited resource, and the use of land should aim for not only economic development but also the improvement of people’s wellbeing. Having leasehold apartments means that there are opportunities for re-development or repurposing of the land when the lease expires, to better serve the social needs of the future.

In terms of property value, the perceived value of freehold apartments tends to be higher than leasehold apartments. Yet, value is not only about price but also counts other factors like amenities, accessibility to essential services (schools, hospitals, malls, F&B options, sports and recreational facilities, drainage, etc.), connectivity to fundamental infrastructure like roads, bus, metro line stations, etc., and proximity to the workplace. For example, if one looks at the annual rental yields, a leasehold unit with less than 20 years left on its lease, located close to central business districts (CBD) can be of higher value than a freehold one in the outlying areas with limited amenities and low accessibility to essential services.

When it comes to the expiry of the lease, leasehold apartment owners should have a variety of options to choose from. For example, they can pay a lease top-up premium to renew the lease or join a collective sale to a third-party developer for reasonable compensation. Of course, as the proposal is new to Vietnam, more thorough discussions are needed, keeping a long-term view in mind.

Would apartment prices, especially those in Ho Chi Minh City, drop sharply if the proposal is approved?

If the proposal is approved, it will not come into full effect in day one as there are always roadmaps and concrete timelines for implementation.

What I would see is a more stabilized, healthy, and diversified market with more affordable choices for homeowners who are end-users, not to mention more opportunities for investors and developers.

Comments (0)
  • Read More
Vietnam one of the most dynamic, important pharma markets in Southeast Asia: Sandoz exec

Vietnam one of the most dynamic, important pharma markets in Southeast Asia: Sandoz exec

Vietnam is one of the most dynamic and important pharma markets in Southeast Asia, and Sandoz, a Switzerland-headquatered global leader in generic and biosimilar medicines, has decided to invest massively in the country, said Charaf Eddine Kadri, general director of Sandoz Vietnam.

Executive Talk - Mon, December 23, 2024 | 8:36 am GMT+7

Noi Bai, Tan Son Nhat airport terminals to be completed in 2025: investor ACV

Noi Bai, Tan Son Nhat airport terminals to be completed in 2025: investor ACV

The T3 passenger terminal at Tan Son Nhat International Airport in Ho Chi Minh City will be completed by April 30, 2025, two months ahead of schedule, while the expansion of the T2 passenger terminal at Noi Bai International Airport in Hanoi is slated for completion next year.

Infrastructure - Mon, December 23, 2024 | 8:23 am GMT+7

Vietnam’s benchmark VN-Index to reach 1,400-1,420 points in 2025: broker

Vietnam’s benchmark VN-Index to reach 1,400-1,420 points in 2025: broker

The VN-Index, representing the Ho Chi Minh Stock Exchange (HoSE), may hit 1,400-1,420 points in 2025, driven by an 18% market-wide profit growth and a price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of 12.5-13x, according to broker MBBank Securities (MBS).

Finance - Sun, December 22, 2024 | 7:52 pm GMT+7

HCMC's first metro line officially operational after nearly 2 decades

HCMC's first metro line officially operational after nearly 2 decades

The first urban railway line in Ho Chi Minh City, named Ben Thanh-Suoi Tien, officially started commercial operations on Sunday after nearly two decades of waiting.

Infrastructure - Sun, December 22, 2024 | 2:17 pm GMT+7

Vietnam's 2025 GDP to grow 6.5% on robust infrastructure investment, consumer spending recovery: VinaCapital

Vietnam's 2025 GDP to grow 6.5% on robust infrastructure investment, consumer spending recovery: VinaCapital

Domestic factors, including a ramp-up in Government infrastructure spending, a revival of the real estate market, and a recovery of consumer spending, will help sustain Vietnam's GDP growth at a circa 6.5% pace next year, in-line with the National Assembly’s official target and with 2024 GDP growth, write Michael Kokalari, chief economist at VinaCapital.

Consulting - Sun, December 22, 2024 | 2:00 pm GMT+7

Vietnam shipping, seaport stock rally driven by rosy outlook in 2025

Vietnam shipping, seaport stock rally driven by rosy outlook in 2025

Many shipping and port stocks have risen sharply since November on an optimistic outlook for the industry driven by increasing throughput and a shift in container shipping alliances in 2025.

Companies - Sun, December 22, 2024 | 10:00 am GMT+7

Singapore’s Platinum Victory seeks to raise stake in Vietnam’s REE to nearly 45%

Singapore’s Platinum Victory seeks to raise stake in Vietnam’s REE to nearly 45%

Singaporean fund Platinum Victory Pte. Ltd. has registered to buy another 16.8 million shares in Ho Chi Minh City-based utility firm Refrigeration Electrical Engineering Corporation (REE), aiming to increase its ownership to nearly 45%.

Finance - Sun, December 22, 2024 | 9:29 am GMT+7

1.8 km road connecting Lach Huyen Port terminals to be built in northern Vietnam

1.8 km road connecting Lach Huyen Port terminals to be built in northern Vietnam

The Hai Phong Economic Zone Management Board has taken a significant step forward in enhancing infrastructure around Lach Huyen Port by establishing a council to appraise the environmental impact assessment for the road connecting terminals No. 3 to No. 6.

Economy - Sun, December 22, 2024 | 8:00 am GMT+7

Hanoi TikToker internationally wanted for involving in multi-billion-dollar scam

Hanoi TikToker internationally wanted for involving in multi-billion-dollar scam

Hanoi police have issued an international arrest warrant for Le Khac Ngo, known as "Mr. Hunter," a key accomplice in a recently-dismantled massive foreign exchange and securities fraud ring.

Society - Sat, December 21, 2024 | 10:57 pm GMT+7

Unlocking Phu Quoc’s potential to become the 'Hawaii of the East'

Unlocking Phu Quoc’s potential to become the 'Hawaii of the East'

Leading global tourism companies have remarked that Phu Quoc has "yet to receive the recognition it deserves," despite its impressive and unexpected growth rate.

Travel - Sat, December 21, 2024 | 7:20 pm GMT+7

Thai central bank maintains policy interest rate at 2.25%

Thai central bank maintains policy interest rate at 2.25%

The Thai Chamber of Commerce (TCC) has said it backs the decision by the Bank of Thailand, the country's central bank, to maintain the policy interest rate at 2.25%, considering the move as suitable for a reviving economy.

Southeast Asia - Sat, December 21, 2024 | 5:43 pm GMT+7

Vietnam's military-run tech giant Viettel strikes big deals at international defence expo

Vietnam's military-run tech giant Viettel strikes big deals at international defence expo

Subsidiaries of Military Industry and Telecommunications Group (Viettel) signed a string of significant contracts with major global partners during the first two days of the Vietnam International Defence Expo 2024 in Hanoi.

Companies - Sat, December 21, 2024 | 5:36 pm GMT+7

Taiwan’s Wistron acquires 37ha land lot in northern Vietnam for expansion

Taiwan’s Wistron acquires 37ha land lot in northern Vietnam for expansion

Taiwan-headquartered Wistron, a top electronics provider and an Apple supplier, will further its investment in Vietnam’s northern province of Ha Nam by acquiring another 37.1-hectare land lot.

Companies - Sat, December 21, 2024 | 2:08 pm GMT+7

VAFIE seeks to promote sci-tech development, intellectual property policies

VAFIE seeks to promote sci-tech development, intellectual property policies

The Vietnam’s Association of Foreign Invested Enterprises (VAFIE) aims to enhance policies for the development of science, technology, and intellectual property, creating a more conducive investment environment.

Companies - Sat, December 21, 2024 | 1:59 pm GMT+7

Vietnamese dong likely to depreciate 3% in 2025: VinaCapital

Vietnamese dong likely to depreciate 3% in 2025: VinaCapital

The Vietnamese dong is likely to depreciate 3% in 2025 on anticipation that the US Dollar/DXY Index will finish 2025 nearly unchanged, says Michael Kokalari, chief economist at Vietnam's leading fund manager VinaCapital.

Economy - Sat, December 21, 2024 | 11:23 am GMT+7

First luxury railway journey across Vietnam features Indochine architecture

First luxury railway journey across Vietnam features Indochine architecture

PYS Travel has launched the first luxury railway journey across Vietnam named Sjourney, marking a new milestone in the railway tourism sector.

Travel - Sat, December 21, 2024 | 10:09 am GMT+7