Credit growth limits still appropriate in current Vietnam context: lawyer

Applying credit growth limits is necessary in Vietnam as businesses and the economy still rely too much on bank credit, said lawyer Truong Thanh Duc, CEO of ANVI law firm.

What is your view on the State Bank of Vietnam’s use of credit growth limits to operate monetary policy - an issue of great concern in the financial market?
The State Bank of Vietnam (SBV) has many tools to manage credit growth and quality. However, I think that setting credit growth limits, also called “credit room”, over the past decade was inevitable for the following three reasons:
Firstly, businesses and the economy have relied too much on bank credit, so it is necessary to limit credit growth, especially when for many years international financial institutions have continuously warned of high and risky credit growth in Vietnam.
Secondly, the State Bank of Vietnam (SBV) has the full legal basis to operate monetary policy using credit growth limits. Among the regulations is Article 10 on "Tools for implementing national monetary policy" of the Law on the State Bank of Vietnam 2010. Accordingly, the SBV governor has the right to decide on the use of six tools to implement national monetary policy, including refinancing, interest rates, exchange rates, reserve requirements, open market operations, and other tools and measures in line with government regulations.
The government's decrees regulating the functions, tasks, power and organizational structure of the SBV, such as Clause 4, Article 2 of Decree No. 102/2022/ND-CP, allow the SBV to use "other tools and measures" to implement national monetary policy.
Thirdly, although the allocation of credit quotas is administrative and shows shortcomings, it is consistent with reality and the context of the Vietnamese banking market, which has its own characteristics and requirements, very different from other countries, especially developed countries.
There are many specific tools aimed at credit room, with reserve requirements being a standard and effective tool according to international practice. It is true that by using this tool, the SBV can easily tighten and loosen credit growth. For many years, our required reserves have been at 1-3%, depending on the nature of each bank. Just increasing this ratio by a few percent will immediately squeeze credit growth and vice versa.
However, this "blockbuster" tool has its "destructive power", causing the risk of great turmoil, strong fluctuations, instability, and failure to achieve the goal of restructuring and stabilizing the banking system. Increasing the required reserve ratio will hike the capital cost of commercial banks, pushing up interest rates, greatly affecting the banks themselves, as well as businesses and the economy. In addition, banks that still have many limitations, are facing difficulties or are in the recovery stage will not be able to withstand this pressure. Even strong banks that are supporting weak banks have been hit.
A strict policy is not suitable for the operation of a multi-target monetary policy like in Vietnam. For example, in 2023, with the same goal of controlling inflation, while the whole world increased interest rates many times, we made multiple rate cuts. Operating policy tools according to international standards is very easy, but the difficult part is how to implement them synchronously and coping with the negative effects and consequences they bring.
You mentioned the "Vietnamese context" and multi-target monetary policy. How are they related to monetary policy dictated by credit growth limits?
To achieve economic growth goals, it is necessary to set corresponding credit growth targets and reduce interest rates. But the number one responsibility of the SBV, like other central banks, is to simultaneously stabilize the value of the local currency and curb inflation. To do this, it has to reduce credit growth and hike interest rates. Choosing one goal is not easy and choosing two goals at the same time always requires double efforts and can lead to contradictions and conflicts.
There are many other factors that affect credit growth, which is always coupled with risks. When credit demand increases sharply, we’re not happy about the limits, but when demand is low we view the limits as excessive. The flow of bank credit is like that of vehicles on the highway. Although the road is very big and beautiful, with few vehicles, we are still not allowed to go beyond the speed limit. In case of congestion, we must accept running below the speed limit. We cannot request removing the maximum and minimum speed limits.
Some people have called for the criteria for credit quota allocations at banks be made public, helping to make this information transparent. What do you think about this proposal?
That's really open, transparent, and clear, but even as an outsider, I find it not that simple. If a bank is ranked A it's given a credit growth quota 20%, while a bank ranked C is allowed gredit growth of 5%. Other banks are not allocated a credit quota because they are too risky or weak. However, this stops people from using these banks, posing a potential risk of affecting the system's safety.
Therefore, doing so is only reasonable if it does not pose significant risks. In other words, it will only be done when the people are ready to accept the information and the state is willing to bankrupt any bank if it cannot pay its due debt. Now, the Law on Credit Institutions only allows banks to go bankrupt after they have tried to resolve their debts over many years.
This is considered a long-term goal, but with the current state of the economy and the banking system, it is not easy and simple, and is causing a headache for regulators.
In the end, sooner or later there will come a time to abolish credit limits, but we never plan to remove them completely; they will be replaced by another more appropriate and effective measure.
If we want to achieve the goal of development coupled with macroeconomic stability, we must still closely adhere to the provisions of the Law on the State Bank of Vietnam, ensuring that the top goal is "to stabilize the value of the local currency", and the second is "to ensure the safety of banking operations and the system of credit institutions".
In early December, Deputy Prime Minister Le Minh Khai requested the Government Inspectorate to inspect the SBV’s management of credit growth in 2022 and 2023.
It would focus in particular on the central bank’s implementation of assigned functions and tasks in managing credit growth; building, allocating and administering credit growth quotas; and management and supervision of credit growth in the period.
The inspectorate has been asked to submit the results of its investigation in January 2024.
Vietnam’s banking system credit grew 11.09% in 2023 through December 21, up from 7.39% recorded in early November, according to the General Statistics Office (GSO).
The figure showed a significant improvement despite being much lower than the target of 14%, it said, adding capital mobilization by credit institutions increased by 10.85%.
- Read More
Vietnam's leading developer Becamex seeks to become billion-dollar company
Becamex, a leading industrial real estate developer in Vietnam, is strongly restructuring itself, attracting more private investment capital, and reducing state ownership, with an aim to become a billion-dollar company.
Companies - Fri, May 16, 2025 | 5:10 pm GMT+7
S Korea's Hanwha Energy eyes more LNG power projects in Vietnam
Hanwha Energy is keen to invest in more LNG-to-power projects in Vietnam, vice president Kim Young-Wook said in a meeting with the country's Ministry of Industry and Trade on Thursday.
Energy - Fri, May 16, 2025 | 3:32 pm GMT+7
Vietnam, Thailand elevate relations to comprehensive strategic partnership
Vietnam and Thailand have upgraded their relations from a strategic partnership, established in 2013, to a comprehensive strategic partnership.
Politics - Fri, May 16, 2025 | 12:44 pm GMT+7
Vietnam, China firms partner to develop pumped storage hydropower in Vietnam
Vietnam's Power Generation Corporation 2 (EVNGENCO2) and China's Lancang-Mekong International Company Limited (CSG-LMI) have signed an MoU on cooperation to develop pumped storage hydropower projects in Vietnam.
Companies - Fri, May 16, 2025 | 12:27 pm GMT+7
Vietnam market rebound in May: Leading stocks begin to rally
A new wave of stock market gains appears to be forming in Vietnam, opening up promising investment opportunities for both institutional and retail investors.
Finance - Fri, May 16, 2025 | 11:12 am GMT+7
Malaysia's TNB proposes partnership with Vietnam's EVN in connecting regional power grids
TNB, Malaysia's largest utility, has proposed Vietnam's state-owned utility EVN to cooperate in building a power transmission network connecting countries, including a line between Malaysia and Vietnam, via land and sea.
Energy - Fri, May 16, 2025 | 8:17 am GMT+7
New Vietnam-China int'l road transport route opens
Convoys carrying electronic components, fresh vegetables, and daily necessities departed simultaneously from Nanning in south China's Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region and Kunming in southwest China's Yunnan province on Wednesday morning, heading for Hanoi, the capital of Vietnam.
Southeast Asia - Thu, May 15, 2025 | 10:34 pm GMT+7
Indonesia’s rice reserve set to hit record 4 mln tons
Indonesia’s rice reserves are on track to surpass 4 million tons, setting an all-time high after reaching a new record of 3.7 million tons in mid-May.
Southeast Asia - Thu, May 15, 2025 | 10:24 pm GMT+7
China's giant Huadian Group eyes enlarging renewable energy portfolio in Vietnam
Huadian Group, a wholly state-owned company of China, is keen to further invest in Vietnam’s renewable energy sector.
Energy - Thu, May 15, 2025 | 9:40 pm GMT+7
Vietnam’s macroeconomic indicators 'broadly positive': Dragon Capital
Vietnam's macroeconomic indicators remained broadly positive, with both trade and FDI attraction performing well in the first four months of the year, write Dragon Capital analysts.
Economy - Thu, May 15, 2025 | 5:47 pm GMT+7
'How many new jobs created’ should be new KPI for local governments: VCCI leader
With a shift in thinking about the role of the private sector, local governments may soon prioritize creation of new jobs and businesses over traditional growth metrics, according to Dau Anh Tuan, deputy secretary-general of the Vietnam Chamber of Commerce and Industry (VCCI).
Economy - Thu, May 15, 2025 | 5:23 pm GMT+7
Herbalife’s Vietnam earnings hit $75.4 mln in Q1, exceed China tally
Herbalife, a global multi-level marketing corporation selling dietary supplements, recorded $75.4 million in net sales in Vietnam in the first quarter of 2025, according to the firm’s report.
Companies - Thu, May 15, 2025 | 5:01 pm GMT+7
Japan’s Nitto Denko to quadruple northern Vietnam plant's production capacity
Nitto Vietnam, a subsidiary of Japan’s multi-sector corporation Nitto Denko, has decided to raise the investment in its Hung Yen province-based plant by $28 million to $160 million.
Investing - Thu, May 15, 2025 | 3:58 pm GMT+7
UAE Embassy, VAFIE to jointly strengthen Vietnam-UAE business connections
The Embassy of the United Arab Emirates (UAE) in Hanoi and the Vietnam's Association of Foreign Invested Enterprises (VAFIE) on Wednesday agreed to jointly deploy specific measures to lift trade and investment ties between the two countries.
Companies - Thu, May 15, 2025 | 2:37 pm GMT+7
Turbulent times of Vietnam's food giant Kido
Profits of Kido Group, a leading food company in Vietnam, have been lower than its leaders' expectations in the past few years, with its real estate investment and divestment from Kido Foods not being smooth sailing.
Companies - Thu, May 15, 2025 | 2:27 pm GMT+7
Impact of US tariffs on Vietnam’s textile, clothing and footwear sector
The adjustments in the U.S. tariffs are poised to reshape Vietnam’s textile, clothing and footwear industry, prompting businesses to reassess their strategies and operations, write Assoc. Prof. Rajkishore Nayak and Corinna Joyce from the Fashion Enterprise program at RMIT University Vietnam.
Consulting - Thu, May 15, 2025 | 8:17 am GMT+7
- Infographics
-
Vietnam PM urges world's food industry leader JBS S.A to invest in livestock farming, meat processing
-
Pakistani, Indian sugar bans won't affect Vietnam market: association
-
Wood pellet exports down but Japan buys more
-
Additional capital of FDI companies up 93% on-year
-
FDI capital expansion surges 66% in first half
-
Vietnam GDP grows 6.42% in six months