Foreign firms in Vietnam want clarity, more incentives to offset GMT impacts

By Anh Minh
Wed, March 20, 2024 | 9:38 pm GMT+7

Foreign businesses operating in Vietnam have called on the Vietnamese authorities to issue clearer policies and consider further incentives to offset negative effects of the Global Minimum Tax (GMT) that was enacted in January.

In November 2023, Vietnam decided to join an OCED-led incentive to levy a minimum 15% tax rate on multinational companies with revenues of EUR750 million ($800 million) or more.

 A view of the annual Vietnam Business Forum (VBF), attended by Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh, in Hanoi, March 19, 2024. Photo courtesy of the government’s news portal.

A view of the annual Vietnam Business Forum (VBF), attended by Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh, in Hanoi, March 19, 2024. Photo courtesy of the government’s news portal.

KoCham

In its position paper sent to the annual Vietnam Business Forum (VBF) that took place in Hanoi Tuesday, the Korea Chamber of Business in Vietnam (KoCham) suggests that Vietnam takes supplementary measures when implementing the Global Minimum Tax (GMT).

With the full-scale implementation of the GMT system starting in 2024, concerns have arisen over the potential dissolution of the investment tax incentives hitherto enjoyed by foreign companies, the paper says.

The standard corporate income tax rate in Vietnam is 20%. However, for certain enterprises, the effective tax rate ranges from 5% to 10%, creating a disparity. In the event of paying taxes on the difference, the existing tax reduction benefits are offset.

A draft decree announced December 19 by Vietnam’s Ministry of Planning and Investment (MPI) outlines plans for establishing an investment support fund for the implementation of the GMT, along with the associated support benefits, support scope, and methods.

However, this has attracted criticism over ambiguity of the support criteria, making it insufficient to attract the interest and consensus of investors, the KoCham paper says.

They show concerns over the limitations on the eligibility for support as per the current draft decree, restricting it to investment amounts of $500 million or more.

“This restriction may lead to a very limited number of eligible companies, and there is a significant concern that many foreign-invested enterprises may not benefit it notes.

If investments by these companies are deterred by these measures, it could have a negative impact on the business of all vendor companies that have entered Vietnam alongside, eventually posing a potential obstacle to the expansion of foreign investment in Vietnam.

The paper requests a thorough analysis and assessment of the implications of implementing the GMT and calls for incorporation of comprehensive industry opinions into the draft decree, making adjustments and enhancements to ensure that foreign investment companies are not adversely affected.

Echoing the representative of Korean firms, the Japanese Chamber of Commerce and Industry (JCCI) in Vietnam asks for opportunities to explain the FDI perspective when Vietnam makes any changes to the tax system.

EuroCham

The European Chamber of Commerce (EuroCham) also urges the Vietnamese government to undertake a comprehensive review of the tax incentives currently in place.

This includes studying the impacts of Pillar 2 on current and future investors and considering practical and effective solutions for encouraged sectors so that adopting Pillar 2 does not create negative impacts on the investment environment while Vietnam still meets its commitments.

For example, if expenditure-based incentives were to be introduced instead of income-based ones, like tax holidays, there would be less impacts on foreign investment from Pillar 2 adoption.

In addition to encouraging investment in R&D, innovation and high-technology incentives could be targeted to support policy objectives including the promotion of green transition.

Tax revenues generated from Qualified Domestic Minimum Top-Up Tax (QDMTT) could additionally be spent on improving the overall investment environment such as infrastructure and labor force skills development.

“Pillar 2 provides a very good opportunity for Vietnam to consider tax incentive reform, and this should be done as soon as possible so as not to lose either tax revenues or foreign investment, as other countries will impose top-up taxes from 2024 and are also considering revising their tax incentive regimes in response,” EuroCham suggests.

Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh (middle) talks with representatives of the foreign business community at the Vietnam Business Forum (VBF) in Hanoi, March 19, 2024. Photo courtesy of the government’s news portal.

Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh (middle) talks with representatives of the foreign business community at the Vietnam Business Forum (VBF) in Hanoi, March 19, 2024. Photo courtesy of the government’s news portal.

VBF Tax and Customs Working Group

For its part, the VBF Tax and Customs Working Group argues that the current draft decree by the MPI has a “quite narrow” scope in terms of support recipient targets.

The draft targets enterprises with investments in high technology (those implementing investment projects in high-tech product manufacturing, high-tech enterprises, enterprises with high-tech application projects) with investments of over VND12,000 billion ($500 million) or whose annual revenue tops VND20,000 billion ($807 million).

Given these requirements, only a very small number of businesses will be eligible, failing to cover a representative portfolio of investors in the high-tech sector. This would also fail to attract strategic investors as set out in the National Assembly’s Resolution No. 110/2023/QH15 passed last November, they say.

Commenting on the inadequacy of investment support policy and what would be needed to ensure a stable business environment that will retain and attract large corporations, the VBF Tax and Customs Working Group notes:

1. The current draft decree only targets companies with investments in high-tech product manufacturing and enterprises with high-tech applications but does not include those operating in high-tech parks.

2. Companies in high-tech parks have to meet very strict conditions, one of them being that their areas of operation must belong to the list of high-tech fields in which investment and production is encouraged.

3. The current draft looks at the enterprise-level or project-level scale. However, in the high-tech sector, R&D is highly technical and its output is often applied to the manufacturing of small but critical spare parts and component. Given the in-depth application of each, Therefore, high-tech companies and projects are often small in scale.

“If we only look at the scale of each project and ignore that fact that it is actually supervised by a large corporation/investor, we will miss important strategic investors in technology.”

Currently, there are big names in technology carrying out investments and and long-term commitments in Vietnam with many subsidiaries and investment projects. The scale of investment of such corporations might reach over VND12,000 billion ($500 million) in total, but such amounts would be hard to realize for a single project. Therefore, support policies for hi-tech investors should target large corporations in terms of their total scale of investment in Vietnam as a single entity.

4. Large-scale enterprises operating in other manufacturing sectors with total investment capital of at least VND20,000 billion or $1 billion should be encouraged and supported as they involve an entire ecosystem of satellite businesses, including suppliers of components and materials, logistics companies, etc. which are all indispensable.

5. Additional corporate income tax collection under global anti-base erosion regulations poses a significant challenge to maintaining the competitiveness of Vietnam's business environment.

Therefore, in order to attract investment, the Vietnamese government would do well to learn from the experiences of other countries and come up with appropriate and competitive policies, the foreign business associations recommend.

Comments (0)
  • Read More
Vingroup stocks pull VN-Index up for sixth consecutive session

Vingroup stocks pull VN-Index up for sixth consecutive session

VN-Index, which represents the Ho Chi Minh Stock Exchange, on Friday increased for the sixth consecutive session thanks to large-cap stocks, with foreign investors continuing to strongly net buy.

Finance - Fri, July 11, 2025 | 7:20 pm GMT+7

Coca-Cola inaugurates largest-scale Vietnam factory in Tay Ninh province

Coca-Cola inaugurates largest-scale Vietnam factory in Tay Ninh province

Coca-Cola Beverages Vietnam on Friday inaugurated a $136 million factory in Tay Ninh province, the largest-scale among its four facilities in Vietnam.

Industries - Fri, July 11, 2025 | 5:27 pm GMT+7

Vietnam halts use of German ODA loans for HCMC metro line

Vietnam halts use of German ODA loans for HCMC metro line

The Government has approved a proposal by Ho Chi Minh City to stop borrowing official development assistance (ODA) loans from Germany’s KfW development bank for Metro Line No. 2 and instead use domestic funds to avoid further delays.

Economy - Fri, July 11, 2025 | 3:25 pm GMT+7

Seventeen housing projects foreigners allowed to buy in HCMC

Seventeen housing projects foreigners allowed to buy in HCMC

Ho Chi Minh City has announced a list of 17 residential projects located in areas where foreign organizations and individuals are allowed to own houses.

Real Estate - Fri, July 11, 2025 | 3:17 pm GMT+7

Auto enterprises to enjoy preferential import tariff policies

Auto enterprises to enjoy preferential import tariff policies

The Government has issued a decree amending and supplementing Decree No. 26/2023/ND-CP on the export and preferential import tariff schedules, as well as the lists of goods subject to absolute tax, mixed tax, and out-of-quota import duties.

Companies - Fri, July 11, 2025 | 2:13 pm GMT+7

Korean chaebol Samsung’s revenue makes up 13% of Vietnam’s GDP in 2024

Korean chaebol Samsung’s revenue makes up 13% of Vietnam’s GDP in 2024

Samsung’s revenue and export in Vietnam accounted for approximately 13.12% of the country’s GDP and 13.4% of its total export turnover in 2024, respectively, according to the National Statistics Office.

Companies - Fri, July 11, 2025 | 2:09 pm GMT+7

JPMorgan upgrades Vietnam stocks to overweight following US tariff deal

JPMorgan upgrades Vietnam stocks to overweight following US tariff deal

JPMorgan Chase has upgraded Vietnam stocks to overweight after the country became the first Southeast Asian nation to reach a preliminary tariff deal with the U.S.

Economy - Fri, July 11, 2025 | 11:38 am GMT+7

Vietnam government bond issuance surges nearly 70% in June

Vietnam government bond issuance surges nearly 70% in June

The Hanoi Stock Exchange (HNX) held 16 government bond auctions in June, raising nearly VND30.5 trillion ($1.2 billion), up 68.8% from May.

Finance - Fri, July 11, 2025 | 9:30 am GMT+7

Xuan Truong Company asked to make feasibility study for airport proposal in northern Vietnam

Xuan Truong Company asked to make feasibility study for airport proposal in northern Vietnam

The Ministry of Construction has asked Ninh Binh authorities to prepare a feasibility study on the potential development of an international airport in the province, the ministry said in a report submitted to the Government regarding a proposal from private construction company Xuan Truong.

Companies - Fri, July 11, 2025 | 9:18 am GMT+7

Vietnam-US tariff agreement: A strategic turning point toward deeper integration

Vietnam-US tariff agreement: A strategic turning point toward deeper integration

The tariff agreement between Vietnam and the U.S. marks not only a trade or diplomatic breakthrough but also reflects a long-term strategic vision, bold foreign policy, and Vietnam’s commitment to deep global integration, writes Nguyen Tuan Viet, an export promotion expert and CEO of Vietgo.

Opinion - Fri, July 11, 2025 | 9:00 am GMT+7

Apple supplier Luxshare enjoys 0% corporate income tax in central Vietnam province

Apple supplier Luxshare enjoys 0% corporate income tax in central Vietnam province

China’s Luxshare-ICT, a key supplier to Apple, reported that its subsidiaries in Vietnam’s central province of Nghe An enjoyed a 0% corporate income tax last year.

Companies - Fri, July 11, 2025 | 8:00 am GMT+7

Intel’s 20 years in Vietnam: $1.5 bln invested, 4 bln chips produced

Intel’s 20 years in Vietnam: $1.5 bln invested, 4 bln chips produced

U.S. chip maker Intel has invested over $1.5 billion in its nearly 20 years in Vietnam and exported more than 4 billion products, contributing over $100 billion to Vietnam’s export revenue.

Industries - Thu, July 10, 2025 | 10:05 pm GMT+7

HCMC’s new master plan should prioritize breakthrough growth in finance, high technology, logistics: expert

HCMC’s new master plan should prioritize breakthrough growth in finance, high technology, logistics: expert

Ho Chi Minh City should promote university-oriented urban models and innovation ecosystems built on the “quadruple helix” framework - collaboration among the government, universities, businesses, and the community.

Economy - Thu, July 10, 2025 | 9:42 pm GMT+7

UAE tech firm G42, Vietnamese partners plan $2 bln hyperscale data center in southern Vietnam hub

UAE tech firm G42, Vietnamese partners plan $2 bln hyperscale data center in southern Vietnam hub

The United Arab Emirates's (UAE) state-backed firm G42 plans to partner with Vietnamese companies to develop a $2 billion hyperscale data center in Vietnam's southern hub Ho Chi Minh City.

Industries - Thu, July 10, 2025 | 4:22 pm GMT+7

Petrovietnam rakes in $19.5 bln in H1 revenue

Petrovietnam rakes in $19.5 bln in H1 revenue

State-owned Petrovietnam reported total revenue of VND510 trillion ($19.5 billion) in the first half of this year, driven by strong production performance.

Companies - Thu, July 10, 2025 | 4:03 pm GMT+7

Sustained momentum seen across all Vietnam's real estate sectors: Knight Frank

Sustained momentum seen across all Vietnam's real estate sectors: Knight Frank

Ho Chi Minh City and Hanoi saw solid office leasing and apartment market rebounds after the Lunar New Year holiday (Tet). Industrial land surged with record H1 supply and strong absorption, underscoring Vietnam's appeal, while eased visa policies and new direct international flights continue to support 5‑star hotels in both the cities, write Knight Frank analysts.

Real Estate - Thu, July 10, 2025 | 2:37 pm GMT+7