Foreign firms in Vietnam want clarity, more incentives to offset GMT impacts

By Anh Minh
Wed, March 20, 2024 | 9:38 pm GMT+7

Foreign businesses operating in Vietnam have called on the Vietnamese authorities to issue clearer policies and consider further incentives to offset negative effects of the Global Minimum Tax (GMT) that was enacted in January.

In November 2023, Vietnam decided to join an OCED-led incentive to levy a minimum 15% tax rate on multinational companies with revenues of EUR750 million ($800 million) or more.

 A view of the annual Vietnam Business Forum (VBF), attended by Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh, in Hanoi, March 19, 2024. Photo courtesy of the government’s news portal.

A view of the annual Vietnam Business Forum (VBF), attended by Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh, in Hanoi, March 19, 2024. Photo courtesy of the government’s news portal.

KoCham

In its position paper sent to the annual Vietnam Business Forum (VBF) that took place in Hanoi Tuesday, the Korea Chamber of Business in Vietnam (KoCham) suggests that Vietnam takes supplementary measures when implementing the Global Minimum Tax (GMT).

With the full-scale implementation of the GMT system starting in 2024, concerns have arisen over the potential dissolution of the investment tax incentives hitherto enjoyed by foreign companies, the paper says.

The standard corporate income tax rate in Vietnam is 20%. However, for certain enterprises, the effective tax rate ranges from 5% to 10%, creating a disparity. In the event of paying taxes on the difference, the existing tax reduction benefits are offset.

A draft decree announced December 19 by Vietnam’s Ministry of Planning and Investment (MPI) outlines plans for establishing an investment support fund for the implementation of the GMT, along with the associated support benefits, support scope, and methods.

However, this has attracted criticism over ambiguity of the support criteria, making it insufficient to attract the interest and consensus of investors, the KoCham paper says.

They show concerns over the limitations on the eligibility for support as per the current draft decree, restricting it to investment amounts of $500 million or more.

“This restriction may lead to a very limited number of eligible companies, and there is a significant concern that many foreign-invested enterprises may not benefit it notes.

If investments by these companies are deterred by these measures, it could have a negative impact on the business of all vendor companies that have entered Vietnam alongside, eventually posing a potential obstacle to the expansion of foreign investment in Vietnam.

The paper requests a thorough analysis and assessment of the implications of implementing the GMT and calls for incorporation of comprehensive industry opinions into the draft decree, making adjustments and enhancements to ensure that foreign investment companies are not adversely affected.

Echoing the representative of Korean firms, the Japanese Chamber of Commerce and Industry (JCCI) in Vietnam asks for opportunities to explain the FDI perspective when Vietnam makes any changes to the tax system.

EuroCham

The European Chamber of Commerce (EuroCham) also urges the Vietnamese government to undertake a comprehensive review of the tax incentives currently in place.

This includes studying the impacts of Pillar 2 on current and future investors and considering practical and effective solutions for encouraged sectors so that adopting Pillar 2 does not create negative impacts on the investment environment while Vietnam still meets its commitments.

For example, if expenditure-based incentives were to be introduced instead of income-based ones, like tax holidays, there would be less impacts on foreign investment from Pillar 2 adoption.

In addition to encouraging investment in R&D, innovation and high-technology incentives could be targeted to support policy objectives including the promotion of green transition.

Tax revenues generated from Qualified Domestic Minimum Top-Up Tax (QDMTT) could additionally be spent on improving the overall investment environment such as infrastructure and labor force skills development.

“Pillar 2 provides a very good opportunity for Vietnam to consider tax incentive reform, and this should be done as soon as possible so as not to lose either tax revenues or foreign investment, as other countries will impose top-up taxes from 2024 and are also considering revising their tax incentive regimes in response,” EuroCham suggests.

Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh (middle) talks with representatives of the foreign business community at the Vietnam Business Forum (VBF) in Hanoi, March 19, 2024. Photo courtesy of the government’s news portal.

Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh (middle) talks with representatives of the foreign business community at the Vietnam Business Forum (VBF) in Hanoi, March 19, 2024. Photo courtesy of the government’s news portal.

VBF Tax and Customs Working Group

For its part, the VBF Tax and Customs Working Group argues that the current draft decree by the MPI has a “quite narrow” scope in terms of support recipient targets.

The draft targets enterprises with investments in high technology (those implementing investment projects in high-tech product manufacturing, high-tech enterprises, enterprises with high-tech application projects) with investments of over VND12,000 billion ($500 million) or whose annual revenue tops VND20,000 billion ($807 million).

Given these requirements, only a very small number of businesses will be eligible, failing to cover a representative portfolio of investors in the high-tech sector. This would also fail to attract strategic investors as set out in the National Assembly’s Resolution No. 110/2023/QH15 passed last November, they say.

Commenting on the inadequacy of investment support policy and what would be needed to ensure a stable business environment that will retain and attract large corporations, the VBF Tax and Customs Working Group notes:

1. The current draft decree only targets companies with investments in high-tech product manufacturing and enterprises with high-tech applications but does not include those operating in high-tech parks.

2. Companies in high-tech parks have to meet very strict conditions, one of them being that their areas of operation must belong to the list of high-tech fields in which investment and production is encouraged.

3. The current draft looks at the enterprise-level or project-level scale. However, in the high-tech sector, R&D is highly technical and its output is often applied to the manufacturing of small but critical spare parts and component. Given the in-depth application of each, Therefore, high-tech companies and projects are often small in scale.

“If we only look at the scale of each project and ignore that fact that it is actually supervised by a large corporation/investor, we will miss important strategic investors in technology.”

Currently, there are big names in technology carrying out investments and and long-term commitments in Vietnam with many subsidiaries and investment projects. The scale of investment of such corporations might reach over VND12,000 billion ($500 million) in total, but such amounts would be hard to realize for a single project. Therefore, support policies for hi-tech investors should target large corporations in terms of their total scale of investment in Vietnam as a single entity.

4. Large-scale enterprises operating in other manufacturing sectors with total investment capital of at least VND20,000 billion or $1 billion should be encouraged and supported as they involve an entire ecosystem of satellite businesses, including suppliers of components and materials, logistics companies, etc. which are all indispensable.

5. Additional corporate income tax collection under global anti-base erosion regulations poses a significant challenge to maintaining the competitiveness of Vietnam's business environment.

Therefore, in order to attract investment, the Vietnamese government would do well to learn from the experiences of other countries and come up with appropriate and competitive policies, the foreign business associations recommend.

Comments (0)
  • Read More
AI to reshape Malaysia’s economic landscape: expert

AI to reshape Malaysia’s economic landscape: expert

Artificial intelligence (AI) is set to significantly reshape Malaysia’s economic landscape, presenting not only challenges but also groundbreaking opportunities for growth, job creation, and innovation, according to an expert.

Southeast Asia - Sun, April 27, 2025 | 5:35 pm GMT+7

Vietnam's retail giant Mobile World to keep growing even if market stagnates: chairman

Vietnam's retail giant Mobile World to keep growing even if market stagnates: chairman

Mobile World Investment Corporation (MWG), a leading retailer in Vietnam, will continue to grow even if the market stagnates or retreats, said chairman Nguyen Duc Tai.

Companies - Sun, April 27, 2025 | 5:24 pm GMT+7

Japanese PM Ishiba arrives in Hanoi, beginning three-day visit

Japanese PM Ishiba arrives in Hanoi, beginning three-day visit

Japanese Prime Minister Ishiba Shigeru and his spouse, together with a high-level Japanese delegation, arrived in Vietnam on Sunday for a three-day official visit from April 27 to 29.

Southeast Asia - Sun, April 27, 2025 | 3:58 pm GMT+7

Thailand plans to inject $15 bln into economy

Thailand plans to inject $15 bln into economy

Thailand's Ministry of Finance aims to inject over THB500 billion ($15 billion) into the economy to boost the country's GDP growth by over 1.8%, focusing on stimulating consumption, investment, and providing soft loans.

Southeast Asia - Sun, April 27, 2025 | 1:54 pm GMT+7

New southern Vietnam plant to bring 'sustainable, long-term benefits' to Nam Kim Steel: chairman

New southern Vietnam plant to bring 'sustainable, long-term benefits' to Nam Kim Steel: chairman

Vietnamese steel major Nam Kim's 1 million-ton Phu My plant in the southern province of Ba Ria-Vung Tau is expected to create sustainable and long-term benefits for the company, said CEO Vo Hoang Vu.

Companies - Sun, April 27, 2025 | 1:42 pm GMT+7

Techcombank eyes market cap of $20 bln by end-2025: chairman

Techcombank eyes market cap of $20 bln by end-2025: chairman

Techcombank, one of Vietnam’s major private lenders, aims to expand its market capitalization to $20 billion by the end of 2025, said chairman Ho Hung Anh.

Banking - Sun, April 27, 2025 | 10:40 am GMT+7

Vietnam’s private lender Sacombank to trim payroll, acquire securities broker

Vietnam’s private lender Sacombank to trim payroll, acquire securities broker

Sacombank, a mid-sized private lender in Vietnam, plans to downsize its headcount in 2025-2026 as part of its push toward digital transactions.

Banking - Sun, April 27, 2025 | 10:18 am GMT+7

Vietnam property giant Nam Long eyes 35% profit hike for 2025 on strong housing demand

Vietnam property giant Nam Long eyes 35% profit hike for 2025 on strong housing demand

Nam Long Investment Corporation, a major real estate developer in southern Vietnam, aims to achieve a net profit of VND701 billion ($27 million) in 2025, up 35% year-on-year, driven by strong local housing demand.

Companies - Sun, April 27, 2025 | 8:17 am GMT+7

SK may adjust ownership at Vietnam-based pharmacy major Imexpharm

SK may adjust ownership at Vietnam-based pharmacy major Imexpharm

South Korean chaebol SK Group may adjust its stake at Vietnam-based pharmaceutical company Imexpharm as part of a comprehensive portfolio review across the group, including all of SK’s global assets.

Companies - Sat, April 26, 2025 | 7:00 pm GMT+7

Vietnam's PVOIL owns 423 petrol stations with EV chargers following partnership with VinFast

Vietnam's PVOIL owns 423 petrol stations with EV chargers following partnership with VinFast

PVOIL, a subsidiary of state-owned giant Petrovietnam, had 423 petrol stations with electric vehicle (EV) chargers nationwide as of March 2025, through its partnership with EV maker VinFast.

Companies - Sat, April 26, 2025 | 2:53 pm GMT+7

Indonesia expects 5% economic growth despite IMF forecast revision

Indonesia expects 5% economic growth despite IMF forecast revision

Indonesian Finance Minister Sri Mulyani Indrawati has expressed confidence that the country’s economy will grow by up to 5% in 2025, despite the International Monetary Fund (IMF) having revised down the national growth forecast to 4.7%.

Southeast Asia - Sat, April 26, 2025 | 10:58 am GMT+7

Vietnam's dairy giant Vinamilk to be safe and sound amid US tariff storm: CEO

Vietnam's dairy giant Vinamilk to be safe and sound amid US tariff storm: CEO

Vietnam’s largest dairy maker Vinamilk will not be significantly affected by U.S. reciprocal tariffs and global trade competition as its largest share lies in the domestic market, said CEO Mai Kieu Lien.

Companies - Sat, April 26, 2025 | 10:51 am GMT+7

Vietnam's EV startup VinFast posts 192% surge in 2024 deliveries, eyes double figure in 2025

Vietnam's EV startup VinFast posts 192% surge in 2024 deliveries, eyes double figure in 2025

Vietnamese electric vehicle (EV) manufacturer VinFast recorded robust revenue growth in its unaudited Q4 and 2024 financial statements, driven by strong vehicle deliveries despite global market uncertainties.

Companies - Sat, April 26, 2025 | 8:28 am GMT+7

Vietnam’s first rice husk-fueled biomass power plant inaugurated

Vietnam’s first rice husk-fueled biomass power plant inaugurated

A biomass power plant using rice husk and woodchips as fuel was inaugurated on Friday in Vietnam's Mekong Delta province of Hau Giang.

Southeast Asia - Fri, April 25, 2025 | 11:13 pm GMT+7

Bestway International launches $300 mln plant in southern Vietnam

Bestway International launches $300 mln plant in southern Vietnam

Chinese group Bestway International has launched a $300 million investment project in Vietnam's southern city of Can Tho, signaling a significant boost in large-scale foreign investment for the Mekong Delta region.

Southeast Asia - Fri, April 25, 2025 | 11:10 pm GMT+7

Indonesia accelerates tariff talks with US

Indonesia accelerates tariff talks with US

Indonesian Coordinating Minister for Economic Affairs Airlangga Hartarto has met with U.S. Secretary of the Treasury Scott Bessent to promote tariff talks with the U.S.

Southeast Asia - Fri, April 25, 2025 | 11:06 pm GMT+7