Little 'Silicon Valley Bank risk' in Vietnam

By Michael Kokalari
Sun, March 19, 2023 | 7:00 am GMT+7

VinaCapital’s chief economist Michael Kokalari explains why there is no substantial risk to Vietnam’s stock market and economy from the current U.S. banking crisis, thus maintaining the group’s forecast of a 6% growth rate for Vietnam this year, unchanged from its prior prediction.

The sudden collapse of Silicon Valley Bank (SVB) in the U.S., plus concerns about a possible contagion to banks in Europe, prompted several investors to ask what impact SVB’s collapse could have on Vietnam - and if banks in Vietnam have any latent risks on their balance sheets comparable to the risks that brought down SVB.

We expect the SVB collapse in-and-of-itself will actually end up being neutral for Vietnam’s stock market and economy, which is counterintuitive given that the U.S. is Vietnam’s largest export market. Furthermore, we see no substantial risk that the dynamics which negatively impacted SVB and certain other regional U.S. banks could significantly impact the profitability and/or solvency of banks in Vietnam.

Further to that last point, it was widely reported that latent losses on SVB’s securities portfolio coupled with a drop in deposits at the bank were the main factors that led to its rapid insolvency. Vietnamese banks also hold government bonds on their balance sheets (as do banks in most countries but note there are no mortgage-backed securities in Vietnam), and the prices of 10-year Vietnam government bonds (VGBs) have dropped by around 15 percentage points since mid-2021, as yields surged - although VGB yields have clearly peaked, which can be seen in the chart below.

10-year Vietnam government bond yield

However, holdings of VGBs only account for about 6% of listed banks’ total assets and “held-to-maturity” (HTM) securities account for less than 2% of total assets. This is much lower than the 5-10% levels typical for U.S. regional banks, and far below the ~45% of SVB’s assets that were securities held on its balance sheet on an HTM basis (making SVB an extreme outlier compared to other U.S. regional banks).

Said differently, the rise in Vietnamese government bond yields probably generated over $3 billion of unrealized losses among Vietnam’s listed banks, which is equivalent to just over 5% of their combined Tier I equity; no banks stand out as being particularly exposed as having large, likely losses versus their net equity.

Also, although SVB reportedly had a circa $15 billion unrealized loss on its securities portfolio (which more than wiped out its $12 billion of equity capital), the actual catalyst for SVB’s demise was a drop in deposits that forced the bank to realize/crystalize the losses on its securities portfolio. This dynamic is also unlikely in Vietnam.

Specifically, the drop in Silicon Valley Bank’s deposits prompted it to sell treasury bonds and mortgage-backed securities (MBS) in order to raise cash to give its depositors, which realized/crystalized the bank’s losses on its securities portfolio. However, in Vietnam, the government always ensured that depositors were made whole during past banking crises, despite the fact that deposit insurance in Vietnam only explicitly covers about $5,000 of losses.

Consequently, Vietnamese depositors are not strongly incentivized to aggressively withdraw their money when a bank encounters difficulties in Vietnam, because of the tacit understanding that the government would protect depositors in the event of a bank collapse.

The net result of all of the above is that the risk of an SVB-style bank collapse in Vietnam is very low, both because the catalyst that prompted the SVB situation is not present (i.e., depositors are not incentivized to withdraw their money from banks in times of crisis) and because the unrealized losses on Vietnamese banks’ securities portfolios are not large enough to significantly impact their profitability and/or solvency.

Benign Impact of SVB & Credit Suisse on Vietnam

The Silicon Valley Bank collapse is unlikely to have any significant impact on Vietnam’s economy, despite the fact that the U.S. is Vietnam’s biggest export market, and it has a trade surplus with the U.S. equivalent to about 20% of Vietnam’s GDP. Exports to the U.S. had already been slowing prior to the SVB collapse, and we do not believe the bank’s collapse will exacerbate that slowdown since the decline in Vietnam’s exports to the U.S. is primarily attributable to the fact that the inventories of major U.S. retailers and other consumer-facing firms such as Nike, etc. rose by about 20% last year. Accordingly, the demand for “Made in Vietnam” products was already unlikely to recover until the second half of this year, irrespective of developments in the U.S. banking sector.

That said, the U.S. government’s response to the SVB collapse prompted a plunge in U.S. interest rates and rate hike expectations, which in turn helped facilitate an unexpected 100-basic point policy rate cut in Vietnam earlier this week. We are not U.S. economists, but it is clear that the “Bank Term Funding Program (BTFP)” launched in response to the SVB collapse will probably entail significant new U.S. dollar liquidity creation, which would in-turn continue to put downward pressure on U.S. interest rates as well as on the value of the U.S. dollar in the months ahead.

A decline in U.S./global interest rates and a weaker U.S. dollar would lead to an improvement in the liquidity of Vietnamese banks as well as lower interest rates in Vietnam for the reasons discussed below, and as evidenced by the above-mentioned policy interest rate cut in Vietnam this week.

Finally, the news that Credit Suisse is also facing severe liquidity issues - which will also be solved by Switzerland’s central bank providing liquidity to that bank - also put significant downward pressure on global interest rates. This will ultimately result in more liquidity flowing into the global economy, which should indirectly benefit Vietnam’s economy and stock market.

Silicon Valley Bank & Credit Suisse help Vietnam cut rates

The State Bank of Vietnam hiked policy rates in September 2022 and October 2022 to support the value of the Vietnamese dong, and the central bank had also been aggressively draining liquidity out of Vietnam’s money market in recent weeks by issuing T-Bills in order to ensure that dong interbank interest rates remain comfortably above USD interest rates.

However, the value of the dong has appreciated by about 1% over the last two weeks, including a notable appreciation immediately after the U.S. government’s bailout of Silicon Valley Bank’s depositors last weekend. This appreciation, coupled with a decline in 2-year US Treasury yields of more than 100bps over the last week, enabled Vietnam’s central bank to guide VND interest rates lower.

Specifically, the central bank cut Vietnam’s discount rate, which is one of the country’s key policy interest rates, by 100bps to 3.5%, and the central bank stopped aggressively draining money out of the money market. The former move was largely symbolic, but the latter helped drive a 1 percentage point drop in interbank interest rates, to below 5%.

To be clear, a policy rate cut is always a significant event in any country, but Vietnam has a few key interest rates, the most important of which is probably the so-called re-financing rate, which remained unchanged this week at 6%, as did the cap on short-term deposit rates Vietnamese banks are allowed to offer to their customers.

One of the most important reasons that we expect the Silicon Valley Bank and Credit Suisse sagas should end up being benign for Vietnam is because both are likely to lead to a strengthening of the dong against the value of the dollar, which in turn will enable the central bank to re-accumulate a significant amount of FX reserves this year. This would inject significant dong liquidity into the economy because the central bank usually accumulates FX reserves via “unsterilized” interventions in the FX market, which entails an increase in a country’s monetary base.

The caveat to this benign outlook is that markets are likely to be quite volatile in the weeks ahead and the value of the dollar is currently being boosted by “safe haven” buying of the dollar - as is typical in times of crisis. However, the markets are likely to calm down as market participants come to believe in policymakers’ resolve to prevent systemic issues in the banking system, after which we expect the precipitous decline in U.S./global interest rates to support a strengthening of the dong, enabling the central bank to re-accumulate FX reserves this year.

Conclusions

Global stock markets are likely to remain volatile in the weeks ahead, in the aftermath of the Silicon Valley Bank collapse and the bail-out of Credit Suisse by the Swiss National Bank. However, we still expect Vietnam’s economy to grow by 6% this year (unchanged from our prior forecast), partly because we had already factored in a slowdown in the demand for “Made in Vietnam” products by consumers in the U.S. and the EU, and we expect that slowing demand to be largely offset by a rebound in foreign tourist arrivals to Vietnam.

Importantly, in recent months global stock markets have been anticipating that a “Fed Pivot”, or reversal of some of the U.S. Federal Reserve’s recent, aggressive rate hikes would boost risk assets, including the value of developing markets’ currencies. As the Fed pivots, this should allow the Vietnamese central bank and commercial banks to lower interest rates, which would in turn make the stock market more attractive for local and international investors.

Comments (0)
  • Read More
Bright prospects seen for banking, securities, real estate, retail stocks next year: broker

Bright prospects seen for banking, securities, real estate, retail stocks next year: broker

Banking, securities, real estate and retail stocks have the potential to do well in 2025, says Dao Hong Duong, director of sectors and stock analysis with VPBank Securities (VPBankS).

Banking & Finance - Mon, November 11, 2024 | 9:37 pm GMT+7

Taiwan SpaceX supplier Universal Microwave Technology to double Vietnam investment

Taiwan SpaceX supplier Universal Microwave Technology to double Vietnam investment

Taiwan-based Universal Microwave Technology, a supplier for billionaire Elon Musk’s SpaceX, has said that it will increase its investment in Vietnam to a maximum $12 million.

Industries - Mon, November 11, 2024 | 7:51 pm GMT+7

Vietnam central bank sticks to ‘goldization’ fight, will consider open gold exchange

Vietnam central bank sticks to ‘goldization’ fight, will consider open gold exchange

Vietnam’s central bank, the State Bank of Vietnam (SBV), will continue to discourage the use of gold as investment or an asset to speculate on, says Governor Nguyen Thi Hong.

Banking - Mon, November 11, 2024 | 5:48 pm GMT+7

Vietnam records highest rate of online shopping in Asia Pacific: PwC

Vietnam records highest rate of online shopping in Asia Pacific: PwC

Vietnam stands out among the Asia Pacific region with the highest rate of online shopping. Vietnamese consumers are also increasingly prioritizing sustainability in their consumption practices, write PwC Vietnam analysts.

Consulting - Mon, November 11, 2024 | 5:18 pm GMT+7

Malaysia tightens control of social media

Malaysia tightens control of social media

Social media platform providers have been given a one-month deadline to respond to the code of conduct, after which they will be required to register with the Malaysian Communications and Multimedia Commission (MCMC) for licensing purposes, according to Malaysian Communications Minister Fahmi Fadzil.

Southeast Asia - Mon, November 11, 2024 | 4:05 pm GMT+7

Thailand pursues new policies to boost digital economy

Thailand pursues new policies to boost digital economy

The Thai Government is pursuing new digital policies to handle emerging security threats, including the impacts of US-China rivalry on the economy and technology, says Prime Minister Paetongtarn Shinawatra.

Southeast Asia - Mon, November 11, 2024 | 4:02 pm GMT+7

Japan’s Shizuoka Gas to acquire 25% stake in 50MW solar power plant in Vietnam

Japan’s Shizuoka Gas to acquire 25% stake in 50MW solar power plant in Vietnam

Japan’s Shizuoka Gas will acquire a 25% stake of My Son-Hoan Loc Viet Solar Energy JSC, the owner of 50-MW My Son-Hoan Loc Viet solar power plant in Vietnam’s central province of Ninh Thuan.

Energy - Mon, November 11, 2024 | 3:59 pm GMT+7

Vietnam central bank vigilant on inflation, cautious about credit risks

Vietnam central bank vigilant on inflation, cautious about credit risks

Vietnam’s central bank will manage its monetary policy in coordination with its fiscal policy to support economic growth, but it will stay alert about the return of inflation and take prompt action to curb it, says Governor Nguyen Thi Hong.

Banking - Mon, November 11, 2024 | 3:29 pm GMT+7

Vietnam’s first LNG-to-power plants set to connect to grid mid-Nov

Vietnam’s first LNG-to-power plants set to connect to grid mid-Nov

Nhon Trach 3 and Nhon Trach 4 power plants, the first LNG-to-power plants in Vietnam and located in the southern province of Dong Nai, are set to connect to the grid later this month.

Energy - Mon, November 11, 2024 | 2:28 pm GMT+7

Vietnam credit expands over 10% in 10 months

Vietnam credit expands over 10% in 10 months

Credit in Vietnam as of October 31 had grew 10.08% compared to the end of 2023, and 16.65% year-on-year, according to State Bank of Vietnam (SBV) Governor Nguyen Thi Hong.

Banking - Mon, November 11, 2024 | 12:09 pm GMT+7

Qualcomm earns $39 bln revenue, Vietnam 2nd biggest market

Qualcomm earns $39 bln revenue, Vietnam 2nd biggest market

American chipmaker Qualcomm earned a revenue of $38.96 billion in fiscal year 2024 (ending September 29), including 12% from Vietnam, the second-highest portion among all nations.

Companies - Mon, November 11, 2024 | 11:00 am GMT+7

Vinhomes spends $198 mln on record share buyback since start

Vinhomes spends $198 mln on record share buyback since start

Vinhomes, the largest housing developer in Vietnam, has spent some VND5 trillion ($197.82 million) on buying back its shares since it started its record-breaking plan on October 23.

Finance - Mon, November 11, 2024 | 9:25 am GMT+7

Vietnam moves up in global value chain with high-value investments: Savills

Vietnam moves up in global value chain with high-value investments: Savills

Vietnam's industrial sector is undergoing a significant transformation, attracting a "new wave" of high-value investments and the attention of leading global manufacturers and technology experts, says a Savills Vietnam report.

Investing - Mon, November 11, 2024 | 8:08 am GMT+7

KFC Indonesia shutters numerous outlets, lays off thousands of employees

KFC Indonesia shutters numerous outlets, lays off thousands of employees

KFC Indonesia, owned by Gelael and Salim Group under PT Fast Food Indonesia Tbk (FAST), reported a net loss of IDR557.08 billion (over $36 million) as of the third quarter of this year, resulting in the company’s closure of 47 outlets (as of September) and sack of 2,274 employees.

Southeast Asia - Sun, November 10, 2024 | 11:00 pm GMT+7

Indonesia eyes to become world’s palm oil price setter

Indonesia eyes to become world’s palm oil price setter

Indonesia’s Ministry of Agriculture has set a target of making the country the world’s largest palm oil producer by 2025, enabling it to influence global prices of the commodity.

Southeast Asia - Sun, November 10, 2024 | 11:00 pm GMT+7

Vietnamese broker ACBS sees profit surge, sustained capital support from parent bank

Vietnamese broker ACBS sees profit surge, sustained capital support from parent bank

ACB Securities JSC (ACBS) has reported a surge in both charter capital and profit, fueled by continued investment from its parent company, Asia Commercial Bank (ACB).

Finance - Sun, November 10, 2024 | 7:45 pm GMT+7