Taxes on second property in Vietnam require cautious, balanced approach: experts

By Vietnam News Agency
Mon, December 2, 2024 | 10:20 pm GMT+7

Property prices in Vietnam have been on the rise, causing economists and industry insiders to support stronger tax measures to keep prices in check while urging caution in their implementation.

Economists say Vietnam should learn from policies implemented by its Southeast Asian neighbors to curb land hoarding and speculation. Photo courtesy of Vietnam News Agency.

Economists say Vietnam should learn from policies implemented by its Southeast Asian neighbors to curb land hoarding and speculation. Photo courtesy of Vietnam News Agency.

Last week, the Vietnam Association of Real Estate Brokers (VARS) called for additional taxes on second properties and unused land lots, especially on apartments. According to the association, apartment prices in the second quarter increased by nearly 60% in Hanoi and 27% in HCM City, compared to 2019.

In addition, mid-range products have largely disappeared with over 80% of new apartments priced at VND50 million or $2,000 per square metre or higher. In some extreme cases, new apartments were listed for tens of thousands of dollars per sqm.

Older apartments experienced a price surge with decades-old units listed at two and three times their original prices. Price increases for villas, townhouses and suburban lands, while less outrageous, have also been reported.

Industry insiders attributed recent price surges to market speculators and manipulators having painstakingly created artificial supply-demand imbalances for profit.

Nguyen Van Dinh, the association’s chairman, said Vietnam currently lacked a legal framework to monitor and prevent speculative activities and land hoarding, both of which were major contributing factors to price hikes. It has been common for speculators to purchase lands, only to leave them vacant for years, even decades, creating sporadic and isolated supply shortages to drive prices up.

“We identify the lack of deterrents against speculative activities and land hoarding as an urgent problem that must be addressed, despite the numerous foreseeable difficulties,” he said.

Economists said Vietnam should learn from policies implemented by its Southeast Asian neighbors to curb land hoarding and speculation, including imposing heavy taxes on properties based on the duration of holding and if the properties were undeveloped.

For example, Singapore imposes a 16% tax on properties purchased and sold within the last 12 months. The tax rate decreases to 12% in the second year and 8% in the third year. Selling the properties after 36 months from the date of purchase will be free of tax. Meanwhile, taxes in the island nation go up to 20% and 30% for the second and third properties, respectively.

Buyers who fail to develop their lands should also be subject to a 5% tax, which would increase in subsequent years if the land remains undeveloped, a model employed by the South Korea government.

In France, vacant properties face a 17% tax during the first year and double to 34% in the next year. Such taxes should force owners of vacant lands and properties to rent or sell, boosting market supply.

This is the second round for second-property tax, which was discussed back in 2017 but later dismissed out of concerns for its feasibility and timing. Since then, the Ministry of Finance has been working on a series of policy changes to the country’s Property Law to improve land utilisation.

Implementation will likely face numerous obstacles, said economist Dinh Trong Thinh. He highlighted the need for a comprehensive and transparent database to track owners’ holdings.

He also warned the government of legal loopholes that could allow owners to circumvent the laws through proxies and emphasised the risk of overtaxing, which could burden businesses and consumers.

“Every policy must ensure its gains will likely outweigh its damage,” he added.

Economist Dinh The Hien from the Institute of Information and Business Research said a tax on second properties could hurt the market’s confidence, drive prices up and lead to market contraction.

“Taxes are double-edged swords that can either stimulate or hinder growth," he said.

"In principle, taxes should promote market transparency and growth, which can also be accomplished by starting a comprehensive land database and evaluation."

Taxes and regulations do not always effectively counter land hoarding and speculation. For example, strict rules in purchasing second properties in large cities such as Beijing and Shanghai have significantly put a damper on the market, with some experts saying the financial losses have been crippling: a $18 trillion decrease in household wealth, 18 million jobs lost and plummeting demand for construction materials. The rules have since been relaxed, allowing easier purchases of second properties.

Hien said Vietnam, with limited resources compared to China, must tread the water with extreme caution, as a rash decision could send the property market, a major driver of socio-economic growth, into a downward spiral, hurting the economy as a whole.

Comments (0)
  • Read More
Indonesia’s palm oil industry becomes investment magnet

Indonesia’s palm oil industry becomes investment magnet

Indonesia’s palm oil sector attracted IDR52.7 trillion, or approximately $3.2 billion, in investment during the first nine months of this year, with the money going into enabling the country to capture more value out of its top commodity, the country’s Ministry of Investment reported.

Southeast Asia - Tue, October 21, 2025 | 9:34 pm GMT+7

Indonesia reports strong job, investment growth

Indonesia reports strong job, investment growth

The Indonesian Coordinating Ministry for Economic Affairs reported strong job and investment growth during the first year of President Prabowo Subianto’s administration, compared with the first year under his predecessor.

Southeast Asia - Tue, October 21, 2025 | 9:29 pm GMT+7

Singapore grants conditional approval for 1GW low-carbon power import from Malaysia

Singapore grants conditional approval for 1GW low-carbon power import from Malaysia

Singapore has granted conditional approval to import 1 GW of low-carbon electricity from the Malaysian state of Sarawak, marking a new phase in the energy partnership between the two countries.

Southeast Asia - Tue, October 21, 2025 | 9:26 pm GMT+7

Margin lending in Vietnam’s stock market hits record, but not worrisome

Margin lending in Vietnam’s stock market hits record, but not worrisome

Despite margin debt in Vietnam’s stock market surging sharply, experts believe that current margin pressure is not yet a major concern as top securities firms have significantly strengthened their capital buffers.

Finance - Tue, October 21, 2025 | 4:23 pm GMT+7

Lenders in Vietnam now in low-rate lending race: ACB exec

Lenders in Vietnam now in low-rate lending race: ACB exec

The biggest “headache” for banks in Vietnam now is that profit margins are getting thinner, said CEO of Asia Commercial Bank (ACB) Tu Tien Phat.

Banking & Finance - Tue, October 21, 2025 | 4:00 pm GMT+7

PV Gas - 35 years of innovation and technological leadership in Vietnam’s gas industry

PV Gas - 35 years of innovation and technological leadership in Vietnam’s gas industry

Over the past 35 years of establishment and development (1990-2025), PV Gas, a subsidiary of state-owned giant Petrovietnam, has affirmed its pioneering position in Vietnam’s gas industry, marked by a series of groundbreaking achievements in science and technology.

Companies - Tue, October 21, 2025 | 3:45 pm GMT+7

Vietnam's consumer finance major F88 achieves 90% of year's profit target after 9 months

Vietnam's consumer finance major F88 achieves 90% of year's profit target after 9 months

F88 Investment JSC (F88), a leading consumer finance company in Vietnam, reported a cumulative pre-tax profit of VND603 billion ($22.88 million) in the first nine months of 2025, a 2.5-fold increase year-on-year, reaching 90% of its full-year target of VND673 billion.

Companies - Tue, October 21, 2025 | 3:15 pm GMT+7

Vietnam corporate earnings to be driven by credit expansion, trading activity, property recovery

Vietnam corporate earnings to be driven by credit expansion, trading activity, property recovery

With Q3 earnings season underway, results are expected to come in broadly in line with expectations. Financials should remain the largest contributors, benefiting from credit expansion and trading activity, while real estate continues to recover as project launches and sales rates improve, writes Tung Dang, associate director at Dragon Capital.

Economy - Tue, October 21, 2025 | 2:33 pm GMT+7

Inland port opens in southern Vietnam province Tay Ninh, set to become border logistics hub

Inland port opens in southern Vietnam province Tay Ninh, set to become border logistics hub

The 16.5-hectare Tan Cang-Moc Bai inland port in Tay Ninh province, southern Vietnam has been opened, offering logistics services and handling customs clearance for imports and exports.

Infrastructure - Tue, October 21, 2025 | 12:03 pm GMT+7

State-managed property trading centers will help curb speculation, price manipulation: expert

State-managed property trading centers will help curb speculation, price manipulation: expert

Establishment of state-managed real estate trading centers is expected to create a transparent transaction channel, helping control and limit speculation and price manipulation in the Vietnamese market.

Real Estate - Tue, October 21, 2025 | 8:37 am GMT+7

Vietnam's benchmark VN-Index records sharpest drop in 25-year history

Vietnam's benchmark VN-Index records sharpest drop in 25-year history

VN-Index, which represents the Ho Chi Minh Stock Exchange (HoSE), saw the sharpest decline in its 25-year history on Monday, down by 94.76 points, or 5.47%, to 1,636.43.

Finance - Mon, October 20, 2025 | 5:49 pm GMT+7

Construction contractor Coteccons sets record FY2026 targets, capital base hike via share issue

Construction contractor Coteccons sets record FY2026 targets, capital base hike via share issue

Coteccons Construction JSC (HoSE: CTD), one of Vietnam’s largest construction contractors, has set ambitious targets for its fiscal year 2026, driven by a record order backlog and its push into international markets.

Companies - Mon, October 20, 2025 | 4:50 pm GMT+7

Real estate, gold markets to be fully established by 2026: Prime Minister

Real estate, gold markets to be fully established by 2026: Prime Minister

Vietnam plans to complete comprehensive legal framework for its financial, real estate, and gold markets by 2026 as part of a broader effort to modernize market infrastructure and accelerate economic growth, said Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh.

Finance - Mon, October 20, 2025 | 3:33 pm GMT+7

Vietnam breaks ground on nation’s most advanced domed stadium in Hung Yen province

Vietnam breaks ground on nation’s most advanced domed stadium in Hung Yen province

Vietnam’s Ministry of Public Security has broken ground on a 60,000-seat domed stadium in the northern province of Hung Yen, set to become the country’s most technologically advanced sports venue.

Society - Mon, October 20, 2025 | 2:48 pm GMT+7

Workforce and logistics - keys to sustainable e-commerce growth in Vietnam: experts

Workforce and logistics - keys to sustainable e-commerce growth in Vietnam: experts

Businesses and online shop owners in Vietnam should pay greater attention to human resources and logistics, considering these factors “keys” to competitive advantage in the increasingly volatile e-commerce market, according to experts.

Economy - Mon, October 20, 2025 | 10:54 am GMT+7

Construction stocks ignite Vietnam’s market rally by year-end

Construction stocks ignite Vietnam’s market rally by year-end

FDI inflows into Vietnam are hitting record highs, while faster public investment disbursement and stable construction material costs are fueling a late-year surge in construction stocks, analysts said.

Finance - Mon, October 20, 2025 | 10:44 am GMT+7