Vietnam’s lending institutions lack responsibility: police official

By Thai Son
Mon, April 24, 2023 | 9:31 am GMT+7

Some consumer finance institutions in Vietnam have failed to fulfil their responsibilities by providing loans without vetting borrowers thoroughly, said Lieutenant General Tran Ngoc Ha, director of the Criminal Police Department.

Lieutenant General Tran Ngoc Ha, director of the Criminal Police Department. Photo by The Investor/Thai Son.

Lieutenant General Tran Ngoc Ha, director of the Criminal Police Department. Photo by The Investor/Thai Son.

The Ministry of Public Security and local police have been investigating and cracking down on some organizations and individuals that are acting as consumer finance providers or pawnbrokers. How is the Criminal Police Department tackling these cases?

The Ministry of Public Security identified this problem at an early stage, and following direction from ministry leaders, the police have been taking drastic measures to put an end to it. It is also a wake-up call for organizations and individuals operating in the field of consumer finance to comply with the law.

Investigations show that debt collection, smear campaigns and emotional blackmail are manifestations of this issue, and lead to property appropriation. Their methods and schemes have evolved. Traditionally, the lender and borrower needed to meet to make a transaction, but now transactions are conducted via an app. Some lenders set interest rates of a maximum of 20% per year as determined by the State Bank of Vietnam, but charge many add-on fees. They also use more sophisticated measures to collect debts, leading to property extortion.

Police have uncovered violations in consumer lending at financial institutions and pawnbrokers. What are the manifestations of these violations?

There are legal regulations covering these areas. Financial companies operate under the Law on Credit Institutions, while pawnbroking is a conditional business activity. These companies can operate providing they don't break the law and meet all business conditions. Of course, they must be responsible for their activities. We will continue to evaluate any violations, but there are potential risks in each of these areas.

Currently, there are about 28,000 pawnshops nationwide. Interest rates must not exceed 20% per year as stipulated in the Civil Code. However, some pawnbrokers introduced many additional fees, so the actual interest rates are exorbitant. The nature of pawnshop operations is not "black" credit, but usurers take advantage of these activities to operate. Furthermore, they also abuse loopholes in legal regulations, for example a regulation that to access a loan, the borrower must have collateral with or without an ownership certificate.

Some consumer finance companies offer quite reasonable interest rates and comply with rules set by the central bank, but their loan capital and debt collection show many problems.

To prevent these risks, borrowers and lenders must clearly understand and abide by their responsibilities and obligations in terms of their civil commitments.

One emerging phenomenon in recent times that has caused public outrage is debt collection, with threatening phone calls being made to debtors’ relatives. Some argue that although debt collection service is banned under the Law on Investment, it has not completely disappeared but instead been disguised in different forms. What is your opinion?

This issue has also been identified and evaluated by the Ministry of Public Security. Recent investigations show that consumer finance organizations have hired law firms to collect debts. In fact, law firms only provide legal advice, but they are directly in charge of debt collection. Thus, they take advantage of legal advice to collect debts illegally. If they use intimidation or other means to collect debts illegally, that is property expropriation.

According to many consumer finance organizations, there are specific legal provisions regarding debt collection activities. However, insufficient and weak sanctions have hindered their operations. Do you agree?

The police's main responsibility is to prevent crime and ensure social order and safety, while solving the difficulties facing enterprises is down to state management agencies. However, when a lender provides a loan, it must assess the borrower’s repayment ability. Credit institutions and banks must have lending and debt collection plans in place.

When we agree a loan, we must know the borrower’s purpose and their repayment capacity. It is impossible to lend money to a person without knowing their income or purpose.

State credit covers all people and but to get a bank loan, borrowers must meet the set criteria, standards and conditions.

Many financial organizations do not know where the borrower lives or if the documents provided are fake or real because lending procedures are conducted through an app or online. They must establish how people will be able to repay them. If finance organizations do not follow these rules, I think they fail to fulfill their responsibilities.

Police search the headquarters of Viet Law firm in Tien Giang province, Vietnam's Mekong Delta. Photo courtesy of Tien Giang police.

Police search the headquarters of Viet Law firm in Tien Giang province, Vietnam's Mekong Delta. Photo courtesy of Tien Giang police.

Do many people take out loans and then renege on them?

If a person borrows money for the right reasons such as solving economic difficulties over a certain period, they have an obligation to repay the debt. If not, the civil dispute can be resolved in court. If they intentionally evades the debt, that violates the law. In this sense, lending institutions also have a responsibility to prevent this from happening.

Police are the main force behind detecting black credit-related cases. What do you think the shortcomings and limitations are in the field of consumer lending that may hinder competent forces from ensuring social order and safety?

In my opinion, there are two problems. The first is lending interest rates. The Civil Code stipulates that loan interest rates should not exceed 20% per year. However, the rate to be criminally prosecuted for loansharking is 100% per year, five times higher than the permitted level. It is a loophole, and competent authorities should consider amending this regulation.

Second, Vietnam needs stricter regulations to deal with civil issues related to borrowing and lending activities. In some countries, borrowers are required to show collateral to guarantee debt repayments. For example, pawnbrokers should ask borrowers to prove assets as collateral before they agree a loan. As for unsecured loans, the lender has the right to issue or not. Lending institutions cannot provide loans without vetting borrowers, and then use illegal measures to force them to repay debts.

Since November 2022, the Ministry of Public Security has directed Ho Chi Minh City police to crack down on six asset expropriation groups in the shadow of financial companies. The Ho Chi Minh City investigation agency has initiated legal proceedings against 64 people for appropriating property, as well as conducted administrative inspections on other companies.

In mid-February 2023, police in Tien Giang province in the Mekong Delta arrested 60 individuals from the Viet Law firm for asset expropriation through illegal debt collection. They included two deputy directors, 20 division heads, one secretary and 31 employees.

Comments (0)
  • Read More
Termination of feed-in-tariff mechanism a major bottleneck in Vietnam’s electricity transition: expert

Termination of feed-in-tariff mechanism a major bottleneck in Vietnam’s electricity transition: expert

A major bottleneck in Vietnam’s electricity transition has been the termination of the feed-in-tariff (FIT) mechanism in 2021, with no suitable replacement mechanism in place, according to the director of Hanoi-based Institute of Energy Technology.

Economy - Mon, June 2, 2025 | 4:56 pm GMT+7

Vietnam Vaccine JSC launches high-quality healthcare shop chain

Vietnam Vaccine JSC launches high-quality healthcare shop chain

Vietnam Vaccine JSC (VNVC), well known for its vacciation services, on Saturday launched its VNVC Shop, a chain offering safe, high-quality healthcare products from globally recognized brands.

Companies - Mon, June 2, 2025 | 4:05 pm GMT+7

Vietnam heavyweight PV Gas plans $3 bln investment over next 5 years

Vietnam heavyweight PV Gas plans $3 bln investment over next 5 years

PV Gas, a subsidiary of state-owned giant Petrovietnam, plans to make "strong investment" over the next five years in areas such as infrastructure and import-distribution of LNG.

Energy - Mon, June 2, 2025 | 2:01 pm GMT+7

Vietnam sees renewed output expansion, improved business confidence in May: S&P Global

Vietnam sees renewed output expansion, improved business confidence in May: S&P Global

May saw a more stable picture in terms of U.S. tariff policies than April, helping lead to a renewed expansion in output and improved business confidence, says Andrew Harker, economics director at S&P Global Market Intelligence.

Economy - Mon, June 2, 2025 | 9:18 am GMT+7

Vietnam considers developing 2 inter-regional renewable energy service and industry hubs

Vietnam considers developing 2 inter-regional renewable energy service and industry hubs

The Ministry of Industry and Trade (MoIT) has proposed building two inter-regional renewable energy service and industry hubs in the country.

Economy - Mon, June 2, 2025 | 8:00 am GMT+7

Investors advised to take profits from stocks having risen sharply

Investors advised to take profits from stocks having risen sharply

Investors should maintain a balanced stock allocation in their portfolios and consider buying opportunities if the VN-Index retreats to the 1,300-1,320 point range, say market experts.

Finance - Sun, June 1, 2025 | 8:10 pm GMT+7

Shares of Vietnam's leading jewelry maker PNJ jump over 30% ahead of gold inspection report

Shares of Vietnam's leading jewelry maker PNJ jump over 30% ahead of gold inspection report

Shares of Phu Nhuan Jewelry JSC (PNJ), a leading jewelry producer in Vietnam, rallied sharply ahead of the central bank’s Friday release of its gold market inspection findings.

Companies - Sun, June 1, 2025 | 1:14 pm GMT+7

Vietnamese firm takes over 40-year-old Pierre Cardin shoe chain in Thailand

Vietnamese firm takes over 40-year-old Pierre Cardin shoe chain in Thailand

Emall Vietnam, which owns a network of 100 high-end business shoe stores under the Pierre Cardin and Oscar brands in Vietnam, has taken over the entire Pierre Cardin shoe system in Thailand.

Companies - Sun, June 1, 2025 | 10:29 am GMT+7

Southern Vietnam province Ba Ria-Vung Tau okays 53 projects

Southern Vietnam province Ba Ria-Vung Tau okays 53 projects

Ba Ria-Vung Tau authorities on Friday granted in-principle approvals or investment registration certificates for 53 projects, including a green light for a $400 million investment capital hike of the $5.4 billion Long Son Petrochemicals Complex.

Industries - Sun, June 1, 2025 | 8:00 am GMT+7

Who to receive over 97 mln ESOP shares from Vietnam's leading developer Novaland 

Who to receive over 97 mln ESOP shares from Vietnam's leading developer Novaland 

Novaland, a major real estate developer in Vietnam, will simultaneously implement plans to issue bonus shares and offer ESOP (employee stock ownership plan) shares, with a total issuance rate of 5%, equivalent to more than 97 million units.

Companies - Sat, May 31, 2025 | 11:09 pm GMT+7

Vietnam billionaire Pham Nhat Vuong to contribute 48 mln Vingroup shares to VinSpeed

Vietnam billionaire Pham Nhat Vuong to contribute 48 mln Vingroup shares to VinSpeed

Billionaire Pham Nhat Vuong has registered to transfer more than 48 million Vingroup (VIC) shares to the newly-established VinSpeed that registered to build the North-South high-speed railway project.

Companies - Sat, May 31, 2025 | 7:14 pm GMT+7

Two investors propose $65 mln wind power project in central Vietnam

Two investors propose $65 mln wind power project in central Vietnam

A consortium of Quang Tri Renewable Energy Investment JSC and Win Power Holding Pte Ltd, and Nam Binh Wind Power JSC have submitted an application to implement a 48-megawatt wind power plant in the central province of Quang Tri.

Energy - Sat, May 31, 2025 | 3:10 pm GMT+7

Central Vietnam city seeks investors for $209 mln LNG, LPG terminal project

Central Vietnam city seeks investors for $209 mln LNG, LPG terminal project

The central city of Danang is calling for investment in an LNG and LPG terminal project worth over VND5.43 trillion ($208.7 million).

Infrastructure - Sat, May 31, 2025 | 10:52 am GMT+7

Thai-backed food giant C.P. Vietnam rejects pork safety accusations 

Thai-backed food giant C.P. Vietnam rejects pork safety accusations 

C.P. Vietnam, a subsidiary of Thailand’s food giant Charoen Pokphand Foods Public Company Limited (CPF), has dismissed social media allegations of selling diseased pork, calling them fabricated and false.

Companies - Sat, May 31, 2025 | 8:54 am GMT+7

Oman Investment Authority to expand investment fund in Vietnam

Oman Investment Authority to expand investment fund in Vietnam

Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh has proposed Oman to enlarge the Vietnam-Oman Investment Fund (VOI) to $1 billion to better cater for the Southeast Asian country's investment needs.

Economy - Fri, May 30, 2025 | 11:26 pm GMT+7

Japanese retailer Aeon to build 2-hectare mall in Vietnam’s Mekong Delta

Japanese retailer Aeon to build 2-hectare mall in Vietnam’s Mekong Delta

Retail giant Aeon will develop a 2-hectare mall in the Mekong Delta province of Tien Giang, with an estimated investment of VND1.16 trillion ($44.6 million).

Industries - Fri, May 30, 2025 | 4:44 pm GMT+7