Credit crunch impact over Vietnam stocks could ease soon
VinaCapital’s chief economist Michael Kokalari explains why the “credit crunch” concerns in Vietnam's stock market could abate soon.
November 16 was a dramatic day for the Vietnamese stock market. The VN-Index plunged by more than 4% soon after opening; but ended the day up over 3% on hopes that the “credit crunch” concerns that made Vietnam one of the worst performing markets in the world this year could be abating.
In short, the country’s real estate developers have been facing increasing difficulties accessing credit this year and concerns that this “credit crunch” among developers could spread to other sectors of the economy have pushed the VN-Index down as much as 42% in the year to date (YTD).
The plunge has been driven by a circa 50% YTD sell-off in real estate stocks and 40% sell-off in bank stocks, given that the combined weighting of these two sectors accounts for 55% of the index. The VN-Index dramatically underperformed the average of its regional peers’ stock markets (Indonesia/Malaysia/Thailand/Philippines), as can be seen below, owing in part to concerns about the ability of real estate developers to refinance over $5 billion of maturing debts in 2023.
We believe Vietnam’s stock market is now overestimating the impact of the recent tightening of credit conditions for the country’s real estate developers to the rest of the economy. It is important to note that real estate development contributes less than 10% of Vietnam’s GDP, in contrast to nearly 30% in China.
VinaCapital’s analysts directly canvassed several industrial companies and concluded that the current credit crunch primarily impacts real estate developers and some smaller companies. Large industrial companies (for instance, non-real estate developers) appear to continue to have access to credit - albeit at higher interest rates.
We also believe investors are overestimating how long this situation is likely to persist; and expect the government to take action to alleviate the liquidity issues that are depressing Vietnamese stock prices well in advance of the Lunar New Year holiday (at the end of January), when both economic activity and the demand for liquidity in Vietnam are elevated.
These issues are relatively straight-forward for policy makers to address, so hints from government officials about the steps they could take to alleviate the situation sent stocks soaring on November 16 and that informal guidance was followed up by the formation of a task force to address issues in the real estate sector by Vietnam’s Prime Minister later in the week.
Finally, Vietnam’s GDP is on-track to grow by 8% in 2022 and by nearly 6% in 2023, while corporate earnings are on track to grow by 17% this year and next. The combination of falling stock prices and growing earnings caused the FY22 P/E multiple for the VN-Index to plunge from above 17x at the beginning of 2022 to 9x now, and the market’s 8x FY23 P/E is 40% below the forward P/E valuation of Vietnam’s regional peers.
“Credit crunch” is not endemic
Our canvass of companies in a variety of industries leads us to believe that large, high-quality companies outside the real estate sector are not facing difficulties rolling over their outstanding debts. That said, local banks have become more selective in their lending, and the State Bank of Vietnam's (SBV) recent tightening of monetary conditions in Vietnam (it hiked policy rates by 200 bps YTD to 6%), plus its use of its FX reserves to support the value of the Vietnamese dong are both also constricting overall credit conditions.
Further to that last point, Vietnam’s outstanding credit grew by 11.4% YTD as of October 20, far outpacing system-wide bank deposit growth of 4.8% YTD, but we estimate that bank deposit growth would have been around 9% YTD were it not for the SBV expending an estimated $20 billion of its FX reserves to support the value of the VND.
Note also that the SBV assigns Vietnamese banks annual credit quotas, which equates to about 14% system-wide credit growth in 2022. The rumors that sent the market surging on November 16 included speculation that the SBV will increase banks’ credit quotas by another 2 percentage points (the 2022 credit growth quota was lifted by about 1 percentage point in October), and that the government could set up a new asset management company (AMC) to provide liquidity to the corporate bond market - which is dominated by real estate developers.
Understanding real estate developers’ credit crunch
Vietnamese real estate developers do not have access to sufficient long-term funding to support their “land banking” activities. From the time that a developer purchases a plot of raw land to the time that land has been rezoned for residential use and the final apartment building/housing units constructed generally takes five years. The raw land plot does not become “bankable” until the land has been rezoned for residential usage and project approvals have been secured.
Until proper project approvals have been secured, developers cannot use land as collateral to secure bank loans, and even when the appropriate legal documentation has been secured. First, banks generally only want to loan money out for a relatively short-time horizon (e.g., for about two years it takes to construct an apartment building). Second, the SBV recently started encouraging banks to lend directly to home purchasers (for example, mortgage lending) rather than to real estate developers. In addition, Vietnamese property developers are limited in their use of “pre-sales” funding, and can only collect payments from home buyers after the building’s foundation is laid.
The net result of all of the above, is that developers began funding their land banking via the corporate bond market in recent years, causing issuances to skyrocket from $12 billion in 2019 to $32 billion in 2021. Developers faced less restrictive covenants on bonds they issued, or they essentially disregarded the covenants (which has been the main thrust of the government’s recent regulatory crackdown on the country’s nascent bond market), primarily because many corporate bonds were sold to retail investors. Note that the bonds that retail investors bought typically have a two-three-year maturity and pay 10-12% coupons versus about 7% interest rates on 18-month bank deposits in 2021.
The first problem with this situation is that developers now face a major “Asset Liability Mismatch (ALM)” because they essentially need to re-pay/roll-over their outstanding debts every two years, but the raw land they purchased will not generate cashflows until well into the future; the history of finance is littered with examples of a modest credit tightening causing solvency problems for companies & financial institutions with ALM issues.
The second problem is that the time it takes to rezone raw land has been getting longer in recent years due to various bottlenecks in the approvals process, limiting developers’ ability to refinance their maturing corporate bonds with bank loans in a timely manner.
Finally, there are three very important points investors need to understand: First, the government could easily resolve the situation by encouraging banks to lend to real estate developers (by reducing the capital charge on loans to developers, for example). Second, the government can expedite the approval process for new projects to alleviate developers’ ALM issues. Third, demand for new housing units continues to be very strong and those units are still affordable to a wide range of middle-class buyers.
In other words, Vietnam’s real estate market is still fundamentally healthy (in stark contrast to China’s, for example), despite facing immediate liquidity issues.
Summary
Concerns about the ability of Vietnamese companies to access credit have been severely weighing on the VN-Index, but we believe Vietnam’s “credit crunch” issues are primarily contained to the real estate sector.
The demand for new housing units in Vietnam is still strong and prices are still affordable, so the prices of real estate stocks are likely to recover if-and-when the government takes action to ease credit conditions to the sector. The market recent got the first inkling that such an easing could be in the works, which sent stock prices soaring.
- Read More
Tencent-invested Vietnamese game developer sees audited 2023 losses double to $82.5 mln
Ho Chi Minh City-based online game developer VNG Corporation, has reported an audited consolidated net loss of VND2,101 billion ($82.5 million) in 2023, nearly double its 2022 figure.
Companies - Wed, May 15, 2024 | 5:18 pm GMT+7
Vietnam, Sweden set sights on direct flights ‘soon’
Vietnam and Sweden should work together to launch direct flights between the two countries soon, senior officials said Tuesday.
Travel - Wed, May 15, 2024 | 4:52 pm GMT+7
Vietnam realty stock deleted from MSCI Frontier Markets Index
Global index provider MSCI has removed the stock of Nam Long Investment Corporation (HoSE: NLG) from its MSCI Frontier Markets Index.
Finance - Wed, May 15, 2024 | 4:36 pm GMT+7
Container shipping firm Viconship’s 2024 AGM fails to meet quorum
Vietnam Container Shipping Joint Stock Corporation (Viconship) could not hold its 2024 AGM last month after failing to meet its quorum.
Companies - Wed, May 15, 2024 | 4:31 pm GMT+7
Vietnam central bank likely to maintain monetary easing policy: Shinhan Bank
Vietnam’s central bank is likely to maintain a monetary easing policy in order to continue supporting economic growth, according to analysts with Shinhan Bank.
Banking - Wed, May 15, 2024 | 3:16 pm GMT+7
Coffee prices rise, more businesses go bankrupt: exec
Robusta coffee prices are continuing to rise sharply, exceeding Arabica for the first time in over 50 years, and while coffee growers are content, many coffee traders are struggling, writes Phan Minh Thong, general director of Phuc Sinh Group, a leading coffee exporter in Vietnam.
Companies - Wed, May 15, 2024 | 1:22 pm GMT+7
Thai government wants to sell 10-year-old rice
Thailand's Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Commerce Phumtham Wechayachai said on Monday that the government wants to sell the last stocks of decade-old rice.
Southeast Asia - Wed, May 15, 2024 | 1:06 pm GMT+7
Singapore promotes new mindset in public communications
Singaporean Deputy Prime Minister Lawrence Wong has pledged to hold more press conferences so that the government can better communicate its "thinking and considerations" to the public.
Southeast Asia - Wed, May 15, 2024 | 1:03 pm GMT+7
Jakarta builds one of global largest waste processing facilities
Indonesia commenced the construction of a plant turning waste into alternative fuel (refuse-derived fuel or RDF) in Rorotan, North Jakarta, on Monday.
Southeast Asia - Wed, May 15, 2024 | 1:02 pm GMT+7
Indonesia needs over 31 tonnes of rice in 2024
Indonesian President Joko Widodo on Monday revealed that the realisation of rice imports through State Logistics Agency (Bulog) was only less than 5% of the total national needs.
Southeast Asia - Wed, May 15, 2024 | 1:00 pm GMT+7
Public security ministry continues search for holders of scandal-hit Van Thinh Phat bonds
The Ministry of Public Security's investigative agency (C03) is looking for holders of bonds from 25 packages issued by real estate developer Van Thinh Phat.
Society - Wed, May 15, 2024 | 11:42 am GMT+7
Vietnam gov’t vows to tighten gold market as high prices linger
The Vietnamese government is taking action to tighten control over the local gold market as prices of the precious metal remain high despite the central bank’s resumption of auctions after an 11-year hiatus.
Finance - Wed, May 15, 2024 | 11:14 am GMT+7
Food seasoning firm Vedan earns $174 mln in Vietnam in 2023, down 11%
Food seasoning maker Vedan recorded a revenue of $173.6 million in Vietnam in 2023, down 11% year-on-year, according to the 2023 performance review of the Taiwan-headquartered firm.
Companies - Wed, May 15, 2024 | 11:01 am GMT+7
Nghe An province seeks investors for $38 mln residential project
Nghe An authorities are seeking investors for a VND970 billion ($38.1 million) residential project in the central Vietnam province.
Real Estate - Wed, May 15, 2024 | 8:15 am GMT+7
Denmark seeks to enhance food production dialogue, supply chain with Vietnam
Danish Minister for Food, Agriculture and Fisheries Jacob Jensen is leading a high-level delegation to visit Vietnam from May 14-16, aiming to intensify high-level policy dialogues with Vietnamese counterparts with a focus on a more sustainable food production and a resource-efficient supply chain.
Economy - Tue, May 14, 2024 | 11:01 pm GMT+7
Northern Vietnam province fines China's JA Solar for illegal construction
Vietnam’s northern province of Bac Giang has issued a fine of VND130 million ($5,107) to JA Solar Ne Vietnam for constructing a factory without permits.
Companies - Tue, May 14, 2024 | 10:38 pm GMT+7
- Travel
-
Vietnam in talks on visa exemptions with 15 countries to boost tourism
-
Foreign businesses in Vietnam urge relaxation of visa, work permit requirements
-
Google Doodle honors world's largest cave Son Doong
-
Hoi An among world’s cheapest holiday destinations in 2024: The Times
-
Vietnam’s stunning beauty shines in Netflix’s Tourist's Guide to Love
-
HCMC to hold firework displays to ring in New Year