Cross-ownership in Vietnam banks a headache seen from Van Thinh Phat-SCB scandal

By Dinh Vu, Minh Hue
Mon, November 20, 2023 | 1:50 pm GMT+7

The scandal surrounding real estate developer Van Thinh Phat Group and Saigon Commercial Bank (SCB) shows that violations in cross-ownership and cronyism have become complicated and increasingly sophisticated, posing a huge challenge for regulators when it comes to preventing businesses from controlling banking activities.

The investigative agency under the Ministry of Public Security has issued a conclusion on its investigation into the case of embezzlement; violating regulations on banking and other related activities; giving and receiving bribes; abusing positions and power while performing official duties; showing a lack of responsibilities causing serious consequences; and abusing trust for property appropriation at Van Thinh Phat, SCB and relevant units and organizations.

A transaction office of Saigon Commercal Bank (SBC) in District 1, Ho Chi Minh City, southern Vietnam. Photo courtesy of the Ministry of Public Security's investigative agency.

A transaction office of Saigon Commercal Bank (SBC) in District 1, Ho Chi Minh City, southern Vietnam. Photo courtesy of the Ministry of Public Security's investigative agency.

Truong My Lan, chairwoman of Ho Chi Minh City-based Van Thinh Phat, has been accused of controlling operations at SCB to appropriate over VND304 trillion ($12.53 billion).

The Ministry of Public Security's investigative agency also proposed prosecuting Lan for giving bribes, violating regulations on banking activities, and embezzlement.

According to the conclusion, from December 2011 to January 1, 2012, Lan held a 81.43% stake at SCB under the names of 32 shareholders; 98.74% of the shares in TinNghiaBank under the names of 36 shareholders, and a 80.46% stake at First Commercial Joint Stock Bank under the names of 24 shareholders.

The three banks were merged on January 10, 2012 under the name of Saigon Commercial Bank (SCB), and Lan asked 73 shareholders to hold 85.606% of SCB's shares on her behalf. She then bought more shares to increase her ownership ratio in the bank to 91.545% on January 1, 2018.

As of October 2022, SCB had a charter capital of VND15.23 trillion ($630 million) with a total of 4,129 shareholders recognized by the State Bank of Vietnam. In particular, Lan owned nearly 91.536% of the bank’s charter capital in the names of 27 legal entities and individuals. She directly owned 4.982%.

Lan did not hold a position at SCB but owned a controlling stake of 85% to 91.5% at the bank. With this stake, she arranged for people she trusted to be given key leadership positions on SCB’s board of directors and executive board, giving her control of all the activities at the bank.

Lan was accused of using SCB to raise capital, then directed her subordinates at the bank and Van Thinh Phat to prepare loan documents to take money from depositors, said investigators.

Cross-ownership problem difficult to solve

The SCB-Truong My Lan case will go down in the history of the banking industry as causing unprecedented losses.

Previous major bank manipulation cases such as OceanBank-Ha Van Tham, Vietnam Construction Bank (VNCB)-Pham Cong Danh, TrustBank-Hua Thi Phan, Southern Bank-Tram Be posted losses of only several to tens of trillions of Vietnam dong (VND1 trillion = $41.34 million), while the figure in this case reached hundreds of trillions, equivalent to 6% of Vietnam's GDP, larger than the combined assets of Vietnam's five dollar billionaires.

Speaking at a September 18 meeting of the National Assembly Standing Committee on cross-ownership and large shareholders’ control of banking operations, SBV Governor Nguyen Thi Hong said cross-ownership and cronyism are limitations facing the banking system.

Being aware of this problem, the Party Central Committee, National Assemby and Government have repeatedly asked for a legal framework on this issue, she said.

“There will never be a regulation that can thoroughly solve this problem. Instead, such regulation must be included in not only the Law on Credit Institutions, but also other legal documents to ensure transparency in the operations of banks, businesses and people,” she said.

Regarding a proposal to reduce the ownership ratio in a credit institution, Hong said that it is difficult to control the ownership ratio of individuals and businesses if they intentionally let others take the name. This needs the involvement of investigative agencies, she noted.

Major cases that have been brought to light show that an individual controlling a bank can have an "underground" ownership rate of up to 60-70%, and even over 90%. They sometimes do not directly hold any positions at the bank but make decisions about credit granting, lending activities, and improper use of capital. These violations often take place over a long period of time and are becoming increasingly complex and large in scale.

Comments (0)
  • Read More
Vietnam PM calls for more investment from Qatar’s $475 bln sovereign wealth fund

Vietnam PM calls for more investment from Qatar’s $475 bln sovereign wealth fund

Vietnamese Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh has called on the Qatar Investment Authority (QIA), Qatar's sovereign wealth fund with total assets amounting to $475 billion as of 2023, to ramp up its investment in Vietnam.

Industries - Thu, October 31, 2024 | 4:43 pm GMT+7

FPT Retail earns $6.5 mln in Q3 profit, to expand FPT Shop chain

FPT Retail earns $6.5 mln in Q3 profit, to expand FPT Shop chain

Vietnamese retail major FPT Retail made a profit after tax of VND165 billion ($6.52 million) in the third quarter of this year, while it incurred a loss of VND13 billion ($514,000) in the same period last year.

Companies - Thu, October 31, 2024 | 3:56 pm GMT+7

Germany’s PNE opens rep office for $4.6 bln offshore wind project in central Vietnam

Germany’s PNE opens rep office for $4.6 bln offshore wind project in central Vietnam

Germany’s PNE AG, a leading developer of renewable energy projects, has shown its determination to proceed with a mega offshore wind power project in central Vietnam by opening a representative office there.

Energy - Thu, October 31, 2024 | 2:43 pm GMT+7

Saudi Arabian energy giant ACWA Power ready to invest $5 bln in Vietnam

Saudi Arabian energy giant ACWA Power ready to invest $5 bln in Vietnam

Saudi Arabian private energy giant ACWA Power stands ready to invest up to $5 billion in Vietnam, a senior executive said Wednesday.

Industries - Thu, October 31, 2024 | 2:39 pm GMT+7

Effective M&A deal depends on thorough understanding, value addition potential: Kido exec

Effective M&A deal depends on thorough understanding, value addition potential: Kido exec

An effective M&A transaction depends on fully understanding the company being acquired in order to create added value, says Kido Group CEO Tran Le Nguyen.

Companies - Thu, October 31, 2024 | 1:22 pm GMT+7

No budget apartments in Vietnam, chronic supply-demand gap widens

No budget apartments in Vietnam, chronic supply-demand gap widens

Vietnam saw no supply or transaction of low-cost apartments priced below VND25 million ($988) per square meter in the third quarter, says a real estate report by the Ministry of Construction.

Real Estate - Thu, October 31, 2024 | 1:10 pm GMT+7

Vietnam steel major SMC remains bogged down with difficulties

Vietnam steel major SMC remains bogged down with difficulties

Steel manufacturer SMC Trading Investment JSC has been actively selling assets to generate cash for debt repayment and maintain operations since the beginning of this year.

Companies - Thu, October 31, 2024 | 10:41 am GMT+7

Vinhomes’ earnings fall 39% to $777 mln in Jan-Sep

Vinhomes’ earnings fall 39% to $777 mln in Jan-Sep

Vinhomes, the largest residential housing developer in Vietnam, booked a net profit of VND19,642 billion ($777 million) in the first three quarters this year, down 39.2% year-on-year.

Companies - Thu, October 31, 2024 | 9:58 am GMT+7

AI cannot replace customer service staff: MoMo exec

AI cannot replace customer service staff: MoMo exec

AI cannot replace customer service staff, but it can give them more time to prepare and provide better care for customers, says Thai Tri Hung, senior deputy general director and chief technology officer of e-wallet app MoMo.

Companies - Thu, October 31, 2024 | 8:11 am GMT+7

Vietnam property developer Novaland posts skyrocketing Q3 profit

Vietnam property developer Novaland posts skyrocketing Q3 profit

Novaland, a leading real estate developer in Vietnam, reported its after-tax profit hit VND2.95 trillion ($166.62 million) in the third quarter of this year, a 21.6-fold rise year-on-year.

Companies - Wed, October 30, 2024 | 10:59 pm GMT+7

Thailand fruit prices increase at the end of successful season

Thailand fruit prices increase at the end of successful season

Thailand’s fruit season is wrapping up this year with a notable surge in prices for durian, mangosteen, rambutan, longkong, and mango.

Southeast Asia - Wed, October 30, 2024 | 10:30 pm GMT+7

BlackBerry launches regional cybersecurity headquarters in Malaysia

BlackBerry launches regional cybersecurity headquarters in Malaysia

Canada-based BlackBerry Ltd has established an Asia Pacific regional headquarters for its cybersecurity division in Cyberjaya, Malaysia, which is now fully operational.

Southeast Asia - Wed, October 30, 2024 | 10:27 pm GMT+7

Malaysia faces rising cybersecurity threats

Malaysia faces rising cybersecurity threats

Malaysian users are facing a high level of cyber threats, which may coincide with the rapid expansion of data centers in the country.

Southeast Asia - Wed, October 30, 2024 | 10:24 pm GMT+7

Indonesia to develop 3 million more hectares of rice fields

Indonesia to develop 3 million more hectares of rice fields

The Indonesian government is working to implement a program to develop 3 million hectares of new rice fields to strengthen the country's food resilience amid global challenges and increasing population demands, national news agency Antara reported.

Southeast Asia - Wed, October 30, 2024 | 9:24 pm GMT+7

Singapore’s digital economy thriving

Singapore’s digital economy thriving

Singapore’s digital economy accounted for 17.7% of the island state's GDP in 2023, up from 17.3% in the previous year, according to its Infocomm Media Development Authority (IMDA).

Southeast Asia - Wed, October 30, 2024 | 9:21 pm GMT+7

Viettel, UAE’s Presight to boost Applied AI, digital transformation in Vietnam

Viettel, UAE’s Presight to boost Applied AI, digital transformation in Vietnam

Vietnam’s Viettel AI and the UAE’s Presight have agreed to jointly advance the development of Applied AI and digital transformation initiatives in Vietnam.

Companies - Wed, October 30, 2024 | 8:30 pm GMT+7