Hanoi firms’ civil dispute likely to turn into criminal case

By Thai Uyen
Sun, December 25, 2022 | 9:36 am GMT+7

A civil dispute between two companies in Hanoi is likely to become a criminal case after one unilaterally confiscated the office of the other.

Chairman of Dat Xanh Energy Investment JSC To Thanh Son has submitted an application to the police of Dong Da district denouncing some individuals related to Kang Long Urban Investment JSC for "destruction of assets", "illegally occupying property" and "infringing upon the residence of others".

Hong Kong Tower building at No. 243A, La Thanh street, Lang Thuong ward, Dong Da district, Hanoi. Photo courtesy of Brand and Law magazine.

Hong Kong Tower building at No. 243A, La Thanh street, Lang Thuong ward, Dong Da district, Hanoi. Photo courtesy of Brand and Law magazine.

Unilaterally confiscating office

On December 8, when employees of Dat Xanh Company arrived at their office, located on the technical floor KT2 of Hong Kong Tower at No. 243A, La Thanh street, Lang Thuong ward, Dong Da district, they found that the lock had been broken and replaced with another. In addition, the private office room of the company chairman was also unlocked.

Dat Xanh staff wanted to check the facilities inside the office, but were blocked by strangers who asked them to leave the area. They then called police hotline 113 and Lang Thuong ward police to report the case.

Receiving the information from his employees, Son called the management board of Visaho - operator of Hong Kong Tower, and was told they did not know about the incident. Seeing that all assets of Dat Xanh Company had been taken from the office, on December 10, Son directly went to Dong Da district police to report the case.

“The thing that bothers us the most is that right after discovering the incident, we called police hotline 113 and reported it to the competent authorities, but over the past 12 days, no agency has accepted or solved the case," an angry Son told The Investor, adding that he also sent urgent denunciations to the Supreme People's Procuracy and Hanoi's prosecution agencies.

Confirming the case, general director of Kang Long Company Vu Van Phu explained that Dat Xanh had rented his company’s office but had not paid fees for leasing and services for several years. After repeatedly asking Dat Xanh to pay without success, he invited representatives of local authorities and bailiffs to witness the office confiscation.

Documents provided by Dat Xanh Company show that on December 6, Kang Long Company requested the Gia Binh Attorney's Office in neighboring Bac Ninh province’s Gia Binh district to provide a certificate recognizing an event during which Kang Long Company had hired a locksmith to unlock the Dat Xanh Company office and counted the assets inside.

However, Son reported that at the time, all assets in the 200-square-meter office had been taken away by Kang Long Company. He noted that at the time of the office confiscation, "there were three people wearing police uniforms".

"The lawless behavior of some individuals of Kang Long Company with the participation of several people wearing police uniforms makes us feel unsafe. Dat Xanh Company has submitted an application to the Ministry of Public Security asking for identifying who these are,” Son said.

Lawyer Pham Van Phat, head of An Phat Pham law firm, said that the dispute between Kang Long and Dat Xanh relates to payment obligations and must be handled in accordance with the law. "If there is a dispute, Kang Long should bring Dat Xanh to court for payment, and even fined for late payment. But the act of breaking the lock and sealing assets is criminal as that's infringing upon the residence and assets of others."

The office of Dat Xanh Company was broken by Kang Long Company, cleared up and sealed with a new lock. Photo by The Investor/Thai Uyen.

The office of Dat Xanh Company was broken by Kang Long Company, cleared up and sealed with a new lock. Photo by The Investor/Thai Uyen.

Multi-year disputes

The incident between Dat Xanh Company and Kang Long Company is the continuation of a series of discords and disputes between the two entities over many years.

In 2014, Kang Long Company and Dat Xanh Company signed a business cooperation contract on co-investing in the construction of the Hong Kong Tower apartment building on an area of 5,041 square meters.

The two parties agreed that Kang Long contributes 75% of total capital and Dat Xanh 25%; and they would enjoy benefits according to their respective capital contribution ratios totalling 80% of the interests from the project. Another party would enjoy the remaining 20%.

While Kang Long believed that Dat Xanh rented the premises without paying the fee, Dat Xanh thought the office space it was using is part of the benefits under the contract agreed many times by both sides.

In addition, there is another dispute between the two companies relating to business cooperation in the exercise of the right to sell apartments to customers, which has been brought to the Hanoi People's Court for settlement.

Comments (0)
  • Read More
Malaysia’s investment growth in 2025 faces challenges

Malaysia’s investment growth in 2025 faces challenges

In the context of global trade uncertainty, Malaysia may not achieve a hat-trick in approved investments this year after two straight years of record-high numbers.

Southeast Asia - Wed, May 7, 2025 | 10:59 pm GMT+7

Thaco seeks to remove obstacles to hotel, bauxite projects in Vietnam's Central Highlands

Thaco seeks to remove obstacles to hotel, bauxite projects in Vietnam's Central Highlands

Thaco expects the Central Highlands province of Lam Dong to help the multi-industry corporation remove barriers to its hotel, bauxite, and aluminum projects in Da Lat town, said a company representative.

Industries - Wed, May 7, 2025 | 10:55 pm GMT+7

Q1 proves tough for Vietnam's oil and gas giants

Q1 proves tough for Vietnam's oil and gas giants

Profits for major Vietnamese oil companies dropped significantly in Q1, as global oil prices plunged, driven by U.S. tax policy shifts and the ongoing Russia-Ukraine war.

Companies - Wed, May 7, 2025 | 5:06 pm GMT+7

How much is your identity worth?

How much is your identity worth?

With 87% of Vietnamese adults having bank accounts and approximately 95% of transactions conducted via online channels, how banks can protect their customers’ personal data has become important more than ever, writes Phillip Wright, chief operating officer at HSBC Vietnam.

Consulting - Wed, May 7, 2025 | 4:01 pm GMT+7

Foxconn plans to expand product portfolio at $200 mln plant in central Vietnam

Foxconn plans to expand product portfolio at $200 mln plant in central Vietnam

Fu Wing Interconnect Technology (Nghe An) Co., Ltd., a subsidiary of Taiwan-based electronics giant Foxconn, plans to expand the range of products at its $200 million factory in Vietnam’s central province of Nghe An.

Industries - Wed, May 7, 2025 | 3:35 pm GMT+7

Sumitomo okayed to build 4th industrial park in Vietnam

Sumitomo okayed to build 4th industrial park in Vietnam

With an industrial park to develop in the central province of Thanh Hoa, Japan's Sumitomo will expand its industrial real estate portfolio in Vietnam to four projects amid rising FDI inflows.

Industrial real estate - Wed, May 7, 2025 | 2:16 pm GMT+7

Vietnam upholds 8% GDP growth target despite US tariff turmoil

Vietnam upholds 8% GDP growth target despite US tariff turmoil

The Vietnamese Government is persistent with its 8% growth goal though disadvantages outweigh advantages, with a focus on solutions to respond to U.S. reciprocal tariffs, PM Pham Minh Chinh told a cabinet meeting on Tuesday.

Economy - Wed, May 7, 2025 | 12:42 pm GMT+7

Vietnam's sugar major Quang Ngai Sugar JSC posts lowest Q1 profit in 2 years

Vietnam's sugar major Quang Ngai Sugar JSC posts lowest Q1 profit in 2 years

Quang Ngai Sugar JSC, owner of famous soy milk brand Fami in Vietnam, reported its weakest Q1 profit in two years as its sugar business struggled under pressure from smuggled and imported sugar, though the soy milk segment continued to support revenue.

Companies - Wed, May 7, 2025 | 11:14 am GMT+7

Listing, state capital divestment “blockbusters” new catalysts for Vietnam's stock market

Listing, state capital divestment “blockbusters” new catalysts for Vietnam's stock market

As Vietnam’s stock market enters an information lull following Q1 earnings releases and AGMs, recent news about major listing and state capital divestment plans are expected to be significant catalysts for the country's benchmark VN-Index.

Finance - Wed, May 7, 2025 | 8:17 am GMT+7

Construction of first locally-owned semiconductor factory begins in Vietnam

Construction of first locally-owned semiconductor factory begins in Vietnam

CT Semiconductor, a subsidiary of CT Group, has begun the second phase of construction on what is set to become Vietnam’s first semiconductor chip factory fully owned by a domestic company.

Southeast Asia - Tue, May 6, 2025 | 10:50 pm GMT+7

Japanese retailers step up business activities in Vietnam

Japanese retailers step up business activities in Vietnam

Japanese retailers Aeon and Sumitomo have planned to expand their networks in Vietnam, Nikkei Asia reported on Monday.

Southeast Asia - Tue, May 6, 2025 | 10:39 pm GMT+7

Vietnam's budget carrier Vietjet sees 24% profit hike in Q1 on int’l growth surge

Vietnam's budget carrier Vietjet sees 24% profit hike in Q1 on int’l growth surge

Vietjet Aviation JSC (HoSE: VJC) reported a 24% year-over-year increase in consolidated profit for Q1, driven by strong international expansion and operational excellence, reinforcing its leadership in regional connectivity.

Southeast Asia - Tue, May 6, 2025 | 10:35 pm GMT+7

Northern Vietnam city Hai Phong claims top spot for first time in Provincial Competitiveness Index

Northern Vietnam city Hai Phong claims top spot for first time in Provincial Competitiveness Index

The coastal city of Hai Phong has, for the first time, topped the 2024 Provincial Competitiveness Index (PCI) with a score of 74.84, marking a significant milestone in its economic governance journey.

Southeast Asia - Tue, May 6, 2025 | 10:20 pm GMT+7

Malaysia initiates tariff talks with US

Malaysia initiates tariff talks with US

Malaysia is pushing forward tariff negotiations with the U.S., while implementing various policies to support local industries and strengthening efforts to seek new export markets.

Southeast Asia - Tue, May 6, 2025 | 10:12 pm GMT+7

Superapp Grab appoints new heads in Singapore, Vietnam

Superapp Grab appoints new heads in Singapore, Vietnam

Grab, Southeast Asia’s leading superapp, on Monday announced leadership appointments in Singapore and Vietnam, effective July 1, 2025.

Companies - Tue, May 6, 2025 | 10:06 pm GMT+7

ASEAN’s largest economy slows to lowest growth since Q3/2021

ASEAN’s largest economy slows to lowest growth since Q3/2021

Official data released recently indicates that Indonesia's economic growth decelerated in Q1 due to weakened domestic consumption.

Southeast Asia - Tue, May 6, 2025 | 9:59 pm GMT+7