Hoa Binh conflict a reminder of construction giant Coteccons’ power struggle

By Khanh An, Huong Dung
Tue, January 3, 2023 | 5:59 pm GMT+7

The ongoing internal conflict between Hoa Binh Construction Group's (HBC) board members is a reminder of the eight-year “war of power” at fellow construction giant Coteccons.

During the first days of 2023, HBC, one of the leading construction contractors in Vietnam, became the focus of attention due to a power struggle between its board members related to the position of chairman.

On January 1, four members of the company’s board, namely Nguyen Cong Phu, Le Quoc Duy, Duong Van Hung and Albert Antoine, issued a press release refuting the conflict and requesting Le Viet Hai, also a board member, not to take any action that could hinder the appointment of Phu. Meanwhile, Hai said that his return to the position of HBC chairman was completely in line with the law.

The story of Coteccons started more than 10 years ago, when the real estate market faced huge difficulties from the financial crisis. Mounting pressure forced Coteccons Joint Stock Company (Coteccons) to innovate its business model. It decided to sell 10.43 million shares, or 24.7%, via private placement to Singapore-based Kusto Group Pte. Ltd at a price of VND50,000 ($2.12) per share. The deal was worth more than VND520 billion ($22.1 million) for Coteccons.

A complex built by Coteccons, one of the top construction contractors in Vietnam. Photo courtesy of Entrepreneurs & Laws.

A complex built by Coteccons, one of the top construction contractors in Vietnam. Photo courtesy of Entrepreneurs & Laws.

With the help of foreign capital, Coteccons continued to make breakthroughs with an average annual revenue growth of 45%. In the peak years of 2016-2018, its average after-tax profit hit VND1.5 trillion ($63.73 million) - a huge number for the construction industry. Since then, however, internal disagreements have flared up.

After joining Coteccons, Kusto strongly opposed its business philosophy, especially the main motto "If I get VND10, you will get VND7", the brotherly business ecosystem became a weak point for the foreign shareholder to attack chairman Nguyen Ba Duong, claiming it lacked transparency. The foreign shareholder objected to the decision to merge Ricons, a company with a 15% stake held by Coteccons, with the company.

Even Duong's staff philosophy was objected to by the strategic shareholder, and exacerbated the conflict. For Duong, human resources were the most valuable asset, and he wanted to issue shares to employees. However, the foreign shareholder disagreed and demanded changes to the Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP).

Following disagreements on the merger with Coteccons’ affiliate, Kusto repeatedly asked for an extraordinary general meeting of shareholders, requiring an audit of member companies. At the peak of the conflict, the foreign shareholder requested the founder and executive board to step down to pave way for the election of a new board.

Along with Kusto, another Singapore-based company The 8th Pte Ltd (The8th) - one of the major shareholders holding a 10.42% stake in Coteccons, called for Nguyen Ba Duong to be dismissed from the board.

In response, Duong's side said that Kusto's baseless accusations caused negative impacts on other shareholders and seriously affected the price of the firm’s stock, coded CTD, as well as its production and business activities. According to Duong, the interests of Coteccons were still maintained in the common ecosystem and mergers of affiliate companies into Coteccons aimed to increase its strength.

Duong even apologized to Kusto at the company's annual general meeting (AGM) and accepted two nominations to the board from the opposition in 2020, but the conflict did not stop. In October 2020, the power struggle at the company officially ended when his resignation for health reasons was quickly approved by the board.

After the founder Duong resigned as chairman and was no longer a major shareholder in the company, a series of longtime board members also left Coteccons. The board elected Bolat Duisenov as chairman of Coteccons on October 5, 2020.

At the time of leaving Coteccons after 17 years, Duong confided "Like you, I also feel hesitant to step out of the safe zone, sometimes do not dare to take risks ... But If we don't face challenges, we can't grow. Each time we fall, we learn how to get up faster."

After ending his career in Coteccons, Duong built a new construction "empire" for himself, including SOL E&C, Newtecons, Ricons, BM Windows, Boho Décor and DB.

His new “empire” is expected to earn $1 billion in annual revenue in the near future.

While Duong is gradually picking up sweet fruits two years since he left, Coteccons is facing the risk of losing its position with the implementation of many new ambitions under Kusto and declining business results due to difficulties facing the real estate market.

Comments (0)
  • Read More
Former Government Office chairman receives $7,900 bribe from property project investor

Former Government Office chairman receives $7,900 bribe from property project investor

Mai Tien Dung, former Minister-Government Office Chairman, received a bribe worth VND200 million ($7,900) from Nguyen Cao Tri, owner of the Dai Ninh eco-resort and urban area project in Lam Dong province.

Society - Sat, November 2, 2024 | 9:13 pm GMT+7

Thai food giant CP enters public-private partnership to promote food system transformation

Thai food giant CP enters public-private partnership to promote food system transformation

Thai-invested C.P. Vietnam Livestock JSC and the Partnership for Sustainable Agriculture Vietnam (PSAV) signed a memorandum of understanding Friday on working together to advance sustainable agriculture in the country.

Companies - Sat, November 2, 2024 | 7:16 pm GMT+7

Central Vietnam province Quang Ngai to begin work on new VSIP industrial park next year

Central Vietnam province Quang Ngai to begin work on new VSIP industrial park next year

Vietnam’s central province of Quang Ngai will work with the investor to have construction of VSIP II Quang Ngai, a facility based on the Vietnam-Singapore Industrial Park (VSIP) model, begin in August 2025.

Industrial real estate - Sat, November 2, 2024 | 3:47 pm GMT+7

Vietnam likely to grow 6.5% in 2024-2025: VinaCapital

Vietnam likely to grow 6.5% in 2024-2025: VinaCapital

VinaCapital, among the biggest foreign-run asset managers in Vietnam, has forecast the country’s economy to achieve 6.5% growth in both 2024 and 2025, with the composition of the expansion to change to more domestically driven factors next year.

Economy - Sat, November 2, 2024 | 2:00 pm GMT+7

Major Vietnamese developer Novaland appoints new CEO

Major Vietnamese developer Novaland appoints new CEO

Duong Van Bac, who joined Novaland as chief financial officer in August 2023, has been appointed general director, starting Friday.

Companies - Sat, November 2, 2024 | 10:24 am GMT+7

Vietnamese conglomerate Bamboo Capital posts 36-fold profit growth in Q3

Vietnamese conglomerate Bamboo Capital posts 36-fold profit growth in Q3

Ho Chi Minh City-based Bamboo Capital Group recorded an after-tax profit of VND331.2 billion ($13.1 million) in the third quarter of 2024, an astounding 36-fold expansion year-on-year.

Southeast Asia - Sat, November 2, 2024 | 9:41 am GMT+7

ThaiBev to bag $54 mln from Sabeco’s upcoming dividend payout

ThaiBev to bag $54 mln from Sabeco’s upcoming dividend payout

Vietnam Beverage, wholly owned by Thai Beverage (ThaiBev) will rake in VND1,374 billion ($54.26 million) worth of dividend from Ho Chi Minh City-based top brewer Sabeco.

Companies - Sat, November 2, 2024 | 9:13 am GMT+7

Steel heavyweight Hoa Phat pours over $2 bln into central Vietnam complex

Steel heavyweight Hoa Phat pours over $2 bln into central Vietnam complex

Leading Vietnamese steelmaker Hoa Phat had invested more than VND52.5 trillion ($2.08 billion) in its Dung Quat Iron and Steel Integrated Complex (Dung Quat 2) in the central province of Quang Ngai as of Q3/2024.

Industries - Sat, November 2, 2024 | 8:00 am GMT+7

Vietnam becomes Australia’s fastest-growing inbound market

Vietnam becomes Australia’s fastest-growing inbound market

The number of Vietnamese tourists to Australia has grown significantly after the Covid-19 pandemic, with nearly 178,000 reported in the 12 months to August 2024, according to a Friday press release by the Australian Minister for Trade and Tourism’s Office.

Southeast Asia - Fri, November 1, 2024 | 10:02 pm GMT+7

Study finds shift in Thai consumers’ spending patterns

Study finds shift in Thai consumers’ spending patterns

Consumers in Thailand are shifting their spending focus to experiences and investments, according to the latest ASEAN Consumer Sentiment Study (ACSS) by United Overseas Bank (UOB).

Southeast Asia - Fri, November 1, 2024 | 10:00 pm GMT+7

Energy security, digitalization key to Indonesia's economic growth

Energy security, digitalization key to Indonesia's economic growth

The Indonesian government is prioritizing long-term economic growth through energy security, digitalization, and natural resource industrialization, according to Deputy Minister of Finance Thomas Djiwandono.

Southeast Asia - Fri, November 1, 2024 | 9:58 pm GMT+7

Vietnam PM's Middle East tour creates breakthroughs in economic, trade, investment cooperation: FM

Vietnam PM's Middle East tour creates breakthroughs in economic, trade, investment cooperation: FM

Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh’s freshly ended six-day trip to the UAE, Saudi Arabia and Qatar has produced important outcomes, demonstrating the growing relations between Vietnam and the three Middle-East countries, Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Minister Bui Thanh Son told the Vietnam News Agency.

Politics - Fri, November 1, 2024 | 9:25 pm GMT+7

Vietnam, Qatar look to tap potential for energy, oil & gas collaboration

Vietnam, Qatar look to tap potential for energy, oil & gas collaboration

Vietnam and Qatar have recognized the significant potential for further collaboration in multiple sectors such as energy, oil and gas, especially LNG, agriculture, Halal industry, and banking.

Politics - Fri, November 1, 2024 | 9:02 pm GMT+7

Thailand bans export of raw palm oil until December

Thailand bans export of raw palm oil until December

Thailand's Department of Internal Trade has temporarily banned the export of raw palm oil due to reduced production caused by drought and plant diseases.

Southeast Asia - Fri, November 1, 2024 | 8:31 pm GMT+7

Envision Energy to build $420 mln wind power plant in Vietnam from June 2025

Envision Energy to build $420 mln wind power plant in Vietnam from June 2025

Envision Energy Singapore Pte Ltd, under China-based Envision Energy, aims to kick off construction of the 300-MW Envision Nam Po wind power plant in Vietnam’s northern mountainous province of Dien Bien in June 2025.

Energy - Fri, November 1, 2024 | 8:30 pm GMT+7

Indonesia to ban plastic waste imports from 2025

Indonesia to ban plastic waste imports from 2025

The Indonesian government will start imposing a ban on the import of plastic waste from the beginning of next year, according to Minister of Environment Hanif Faisol Nurrofiq.

Southeast Asia - Fri, November 1, 2024 | 8:29 pm GMT+7