Vietnam not yet a ‘net winner’ of production relocation from China: S&P Global

By Tri Duc
Thu, August 29, 2024 | 11:14 am GMT+7

Vietnam and other emerging markets in Asia are not yet major net winners of production relocation from China, whose role in global trade will not diminish drastically as global supply chains continue to evolve, an S&P Global report says.

China's consistency in global supply chain

In a recent commentary, S&P Global noted geopolitical friction, trade barriers, and industrial policy are challenging Asia's dominant supply chains, especially businesses' operations in China.

Before the trend, firms in the textile and footwear sectors relocated their production lines away from China due to higher costs and wages. The trend has intensified and broadened the relocation to other industries, including semiconductors and smartphones. In addition to moving out of China, multinationals are now more likely to install new capacity elsewhere.

However, trends in exports and foreign direct investment (FDI) show that, overall, the role of Asian economies, including China, in the global supply chains is changing only modestly.

China's falling market share in the U.S., Japan and Europe. Photo courtesy of S&P Global.

China's falling market share in the U.S., Japan and Europe. Photo courtesy of S&P Global.

S&P Global pointed out that China's share of U.S. goods imports has shrunk since the Trump administration increased tariffs on most imports from China, with other Asian emerging markets and Mexico filling most of the gap. Similar developments were noted in Japan and Europe.

Meanwhile, China's exporters have expanded their share of the imports in emerging markets. This matters as emerging markets' imports make up a large and rising proportion of the global total. S&P Global attributed the changes to China's growth in exporting "normal" goods, which outpaced the growth of exporting components assembled in China for re-export to third countries.

China's global market share with minor changes. Photo courtesy of S&P Global.

China's global market share with minor changes. Photo courtesy of S&P Global.

China's export market share rose to 39.8% in the year to mid-2024, from 36% six years earlier, S&P Global highlighted.

Asia's emerging markets grow modestly at changes in China

As data show, the supposed change is far less than the common understanding, and China's share has improved in the global export market, S&P Global pointed out that Asian emerging markets and Mexico have only made modest gains.

Vietnam's growth in share of Asia and Mexico exports. Photo courtesy of S&P Global.

Vietnam's growth in share of Asia and Mexico exports. Photo courtesy of S&P Global.

In particular, for Vietnam, the country's share of total Asian + Mexico exports expanded impressively in the 15 years through early 2020. Its rise was subsequently disrupted for several years amid the Covid-19 pandemic. While recent trends suggest the growth may have resumed, Vietnam doesn't seem to have been as much of a winner in the recent global supply-chain shifts as is sometimes assumed, according to S&P Global.

Vietnam and Indonesia with improvements in share of total FDI into Asia and Mexico. Photo courtesy of S&P Global.

Vietnam and Indonesia with improvements in share of total FDI into Asia and Mexico. Photo courtesy of S&P Global.

Regarding FDI into Asia and Mexico, the plunge in China since 2022 suggests some emerging markets would benefit from the trend. In fact, S&P Global data shows that only Vietnam and Indonesia reap benefits with higher shares of the total FDI in Asia and Mexico than six years ago. Vietnam is the only "manufacturing" economy that has a significant increase of 1.7 percentage points in progress, according to S&P Global.

For absolute figures, FDI into Asian emerging markets excluding China was $24 billion lower in the year to March 2024 than six years earlier. The total for Asia-Pacific excluding China rose. But that was more than driven by Australia, Hong Kong, and Singapore, S&P Global stressed.

Comments (0)
  • Read More
Hanoi terminates Vinaxuki auto plant project, repurposes land for commercial complex

Hanoi terminates Vinaxuki auto plant project, repurposes land for commercial complex

A long-stalled automotive manufacturing project by Xuan Kien Auto JSC (Vinaxuki) has been officially terminated by Hanoi authorities, and the reclaimed land in Phuc Thinh commune will be repurposed for a new commercial and service complex.

Industries - Tue, September 16, 2025 | 2:44 pm GMT+7

Central Vietnam province reviews investment proposal for thermal power project after Thai EGATi pullout

Central Vietnam province reviews investment proposal for thermal power project after Thai EGATi pullout

Authorities in the central province of Quang Tri are evaluating a proposal from Power Generation JSC 1 (EVNGENCO 1), a subsidiary of state utility Vietnam Electricity (EVN), to take over the Quang Tri thermal power plant project, following the withdrawal of Thai investor EGATi.

Energy - Tue, September 16, 2025 | 1:44 pm GMT+7

Amata to sell stakes worth $46 mln in Vietnam units to Novaland-tied buyers

Amata to sell stakes worth $46 mln in Vietnam units to Novaland-tied buyers

Amata VN, the Vietnam arm of Thailand’s leading industrial park developer Amata, has approved a plan for its subsidiary Amata City Long Thanh Urban JSC (ACLT) to sell its remaining 51% stakes in two entities to local developer Novaland-linked buyers.

Real Estate - Tue, September 16, 2025 | 12:19 pm GMT+7

Vietnam already meets FTSE's criteria for stock market status upgrade: Finance Minister

Vietnam already meets FTSE's criteria for stock market status upgrade: Finance Minister

Vietnam has fulfilled the criteria for a stock market status upgrade by FTSE Russell through reforms aimed at facilitating foreign investment inflows into its market, said Minister of Finance Nguyen Van Thang.

Economy - Tue, September 16, 2025 | 9:36 am GMT+7

Banks should be allowed to distribute, invest in mutual fund certificates: Vietnam's finance ministry

Banks should be allowed to distribute, invest in mutual fund certificates: Vietnam's finance ministry

The Ministry of Finance is proposing a key reform that would allow commercial banks to invest in and distribute mutual fund certificates, as part of a broader plan to restructure the investor base and foster the development of Vietnam’s fund management industry.

Finance - Tue, September 16, 2025 | 8:00 am GMT+7

E-commerce boom a major driver of Vietnam's packaging paper industry growth

E-commerce boom a major driver of Vietnam's packaging paper industry growth

Vietnam's paper packaging industry is entering a period of strong growth, with an average annual growth rate forecasted at 10% until 2030.

Companies - Mon, September 15, 2025 | 10:20 pm GMT+7

Vietnam needs support from UK in developing international financial center: Deputy PM

Vietnam needs support from UK in developing international financial center: Deputy PM

Permanent Deputy Prime Minister Nguyen Hoa Binh has called on the UK and the City of London to continue supporting and accompanying Vietnam in promoting and introducing its international financial center (IFC).

Finance - Mon, September 15, 2025 | 10:12 pm GMT+7

Vietnam enforces 8% capital adequacy ratio for banks from Sept 15

Vietnam enforces 8% capital adequacy ratio for banks from Sept 15

Commercial banks and foreign bank branches in Vietnam must maintain a minimum capital adequacy ratio (CAR) of 8%, including at least 4.5% in Tier 1 core capital and 6% in Tier 1 capital, starting from September 15.

Banking - Mon, September 15, 2025 | 10:04 pm GMT+7

Tool for wood traceability management debuts in Vietnam

Tool for wood traceability management debuts in Vietnam

The Vn-WoodID application has been officially launched in Vietnam, becoming a key tool contributing to wood traceability.

Companies - Mon, September 15, 2025 | 10:00 pm GMT+7

Sun Group, US Embassy foster aviation-hospitality cooperation

Sun Group, US Embassy foster aviation-hospitality cooperation

Sun Group, in collaboration with the US Embassy in Vietnam, hosted the US – Vietnam Aviation Partnership Roundtable on September 12, bringing together 15 leading American corporations in aviation, technology, and financial services, opening up opportunities to position Phu Quoc as a new aviation and tourism hub in the region.

Companies - Mon, September 15, 2025 | 9:54 pm GMT+7

Vietnam tops Thai giant SCG’s overseas markets with 9% revenue contribution in H1

Vietnam tops Thai giant SCG’s overseas markets with 9% revenue contribution in H1

Vietnam remained the largest overseas market for Thailand’s Siam Cement Group (SCG) in the first half of 2025, contributing 9% of consolidated sales.

Companies - Mon, September 15, 2025 | 8:10 pm GMT+7

Central Vietnam to have new airport Mang Den

Central Vietnam to have new airport Mang Den

Procedures to adjust Vietnam's airport system planning, including the addition of Mang Den Airport in central Vietnam, are being proceeded, according to the Ministry of Construction.

Infrastructure - Mon, September 15, 2025 | 5:16 pm GMT+7

Vietnam's government seeks to position country as 'regulated hub for digital assets in Asia': Dragon Capital

Vietnam's government seeks to position country as 'regulated hub for digital assets in Asia': Dragon Capital

The Vietnamese Government has advanced the regulation of digital assets, with a resolution launching a five-year pilot framework for issuance and trading. This framework signals the Government’s intent to position the country as a regulated hub for digital assets in Asia, which could attract new capital inflows, write Dragon Capital analysts.

Economy - Mon, September 15, 2025 | 2:20 pm GMT+7

Agribank introduces sizable $4.17 bln preferential credit package

Agribank introduces sizable $4.17 bln preferential credit package

Right from the beginning of 2025, Agribank launched a substantial preferential credit package worth VND110 trillion ($4.17 billion) to support individual customers.

Companies - Mon, September 15, 2025 | 1:32 pm GMT+7

'Precious space' in Vietnam's monetary policy

'Precious space' in Vietnam's monetary policy

The Federal Reserve's continued cuts in 2025, with the most recent in September, are considered a valuable policy "space" for the State Bank of Vietnam (SBV) to maintain low interest rates to support growth without having to worry too much about exchange rates.

Economy - Mon, September 15, 2025 | 10:15 am GMT+7

Vietnam’s central bank sells $1.5 bln to stabilize currency: broker MBS

Vietnam’s central bank sells $1.5 bln to stabilize currency: broker MBS

The State Bank of Vietnam (SBV) intervened in the foreign exchange market by selling approximately $1.5 billion via 180-day cancelable forward contracts from August 25-26, in an effort to ease pressure on the Vietnamese dong, according to a recent report by MB Securities (MBS).

Banking - Mon, September 15, 2025 | 8:04 am GMT+7