Heineken proposal for hybrid tax on beer not suitable for now: ministry
In its latest draft on excise tax, Vietnam’s Ministry of Finance has not taken into account Heineken’s suggestion for a hybrid tax calculation for beer.
In general, there are three taxation methods – ad valorem tax (proportional to the value of the underlying asset), specific tax (constant figure), and hybrid tax as a mixed formula between ad valorem tax and specific tax.
Heineken was the only premium beer brand to make such a proposal, the ministry noted. Many businesses and agencies opposed the suggestion and wanted continuity of ad valorem tax calculation for excise duties.
![Heineken supplies premium beers in Vietnam. Photo courtesy of Heineken Vietnam.](https://i.ex-cdn.com/theinvestor.vn/files/content/2024/08/03/heineken-vietnam-0125.jpg)
Heineken supplies premium beers in Vietnam. Photo courtesy of Heineken Vietnam.
The ministry clarified that hybrid tax calculation would put heavy pressure on affordable products, prompting a price hike that’s “much more” than a hike in premium product prices.
As affordable products account for 80% of the Vietnamese market, such a recommendation was not suitable at the moment, it argued.
The ministry also did not take into account another suggestion from Heineken regarding different tax rates based on alcohol concentration in beers.
In particular, Heineken had suggested a 65% tax for beer with alcohol concentration of 5.5% or below, 70% for beer with alcohol concentration of 5.5-15%, and 75% for beer with alcohol concentration of 15% or more.
Per Vietnam’s commitment with the World Trade Organization (WTO), the excise tax rate has to be the same for all kinds of beer, regardless of their alcohol concentration, the ministry noted.
In July 2023, The Investor had held a workshop on calculating excise tax that was attended by major beermakers in Vietnam including Heineken, Sabeco, Habeco, and Carlberg.
![A workshop on excise tax organized by The Investor in Hanoi, July 4, 2023. Photo courtesy of The Investor/Trong Hieu.](https://i.ex-cdn.com/theinvestor.vn/files/content/2024/08/03/the-investor-excise-tax-0128.jpg)
A workshop on excise tax organized by The Investor in Hanoi, July 4, 2023. Photo courtesy of The Investor/Trong Hieu.
Bennet Neo, then Sabeco CEO, said that “Vietnam should continue to maintain the ad valorem tax method and adjust the tax rates according to a suitable roadmap based on the socio-economic situation, at least for the next 10 years.”
Echoing Sabeco, Carlsberg Vietnam CFO Thieu Hong Nhung also opined that the ad valorem tax method should be maintained in the coming time.
Pham Thu Thuy, chief accountant at Hanoi-based brewery Habeco, was also on the same page regarding application of the ad valorem tax method.
In its latest draft, the finance ministry has proposed two options for raising the excise tax on beer.
The preferred option, based on higher effectiveness in reducing consumption and other negative impacts, is to increase the tax rate to 80% in 2026, 85% in 2027, 90% in 2028, 95% in 2029, and 100% from 2030 onwards. The current tax rate is 65%.
- Read More
Vietnamese people support each other during super typhoon Yagi
As Yagi raged across northern Vietnam, the spirit of mutual support and solidarity deeply ingrained in Vietnamese culture was felt by all those impacted by the super typhoon.
Southeast Asia - Mon, September 9, 2024 | 11:55 pm GMT+7
Thai new PM pledges to focus on stimulating the economy
Thailand's Prime Minister Paetongtarn Shinawatra said on Saturday that her new government will seek to stimulate the economy "right away" and will continue with the policies of former PM Srettha Thavisin.
Southeast Asia - Mon, September 9, 2024 | 11:52 pm GMT+7
ASEAN can hold key role in global carbon market
Indonesian Trade and Industry Chamber (Kadin) head Arsjan Rasjid last Thursday underscored at the 2024 International Sustainable Development Forum (ISF) that sustainability plays a key part in achieving an economic growth of 8%.
Southeast Asia - Mon, September 9, 2024 | 11:49 pm GMT+7
Indonesia promotes green industries
Luhut Binsar Pandjaitan, Indonesia's coordinating minister for maritime affairs and investment, has stressed that the country’s clean energy transition is not only aimed at reducing carbon emissions but also promoting the development of green industries.
Southeast Asia - Mon, September 9, 2024 | 11:48 pm GMT+7
Indonesia, EU to ratify key trade deal soon
Negotiations on the Indonesia-EU Comprehensive Economic Partnership Agreement (IEU-CEPA) are nearly 90% complete, with the deal expected to be finalised this month, according to Indonesia’s Trade Minister Zulkifli Hasan.
Southeast Asia - Mon, September 9, 2024 | 11:46 pm GMT+7
Durian leads Vietnam’s fruit export charge, but serious challenges remain
Vietnamese fruits led by durian have been making their international mark with access to new markets, but sustained success depends on overcoming several serious challenges, officials and industry insiders caution.
Companies - Mon, September 9, 2024 | 11:45 pm GMT+7
China’s Yuchai engine manufacturing technology transferred to Vietnamese firm
Yuchai, China’s leading engine manufacturer, has transferred manufacturing technology and exclusive distribution rights for Yuchai engine products in Southeast Asia and South Korea to Vietnam’s Kim Long Motors.
Companies - Mon, September 9, 2024 | 8:07 pm GMT+7
Finnish fund PYN Elite’s August performance beats VN-Index
Finland-based PYN Elite Fund booked returns of 3.1% in August, outperforming the benchmark VN-Index's 2.6% growth, driven by banks’ outperformance and agribusiness Dabaco.
Finance - Mon, September 9, 2024 | 6:15 pm GMT+7
Vietnam unlikely to meet target of 5 GW offshore wind power by 2030: S&P Global
Vietnam’s ambitious target of adding 5 GW of offshore wind power to the national capacity by 2030 may fall short, S&P Global Commodity Insight said in a recent commentary.
Energy - Mon, September 9, 2024 | 5:52 pm GMT+7
Media giant YeaH1 earns big from divestments in H1
YeaH1 Group, a leading media and entertainment company in Vietnam, reported a net profit of VND29 billion ($1.17 million) in the first half of 2024, a 2.9-fold rise year-on-year.
Companies - Mon, September 9, 2024 | 5:28 pm GMT+7
Vietnam's leading consumer finance firm F88 reverses losses with H1 net profit of $3.6 mln
F88 Business JSC (F88), a top consumer finance company in Vietnam, posted a net profit of VND89.05 billion ($3.61 million) in H1/2024, or VND486 million ($19,700) a day on average.
Companies - Mon, September 9, 2024 | 4:15 pm GMT+7
Vietnamese EV maker VinFast halves losses in H1
VinFast, the electric vehicle arm of Vietnam's largest private conglomerate Vingroup, recorded post-tax losses of VND9,068.3 billion ($367 million) in H1/2024, half the loss it posted in the same period last year.
Companies - Mon, September 9, 2024 | 3:35 pm GMT+7
Gaming silver lining in dark financial cloud for Vietnam’s first tech unicorn VNG
VNG Corporation, Vietnam’s first tech unicorn, has suffered continuous losses in recent years with revenues from its online gaming segment not enough to offset losses from other business areas.
Companies - Mon, September 9, 2024 | 2:59 pm GMT+7
Ten vehicles fall into river, 13 people missing as bridge collapses in northern Vietnam
At least 10 vehicles and two motorbikes plunged into the Red River when Phong Chau bridge in the northern province of Phu Tho collapsed on Monday morning, amid serious downpours triggered by super typhoon Yagi.
Society - Mon, September 9, 2024 | 1:30 pm GMT+7
Thailand’s Super Energy records $57.4 mln revenue from Vietnam in H1
Thailand’s Super Energy Corporation recorded a revenue of THB1,936 million ($57.4 million) from its renewable energy activities in Vietnam in the first half of this year, according to the firm’s report.
Companies - Mon, September 9, 2024 | 10:49 am GMT+7
Sales of Samsung's 4 major Vietnam plants up in H1, but profits fall
Four Vietnamese subsidiaries of South Korean giant Samsung Electronics reported combined revenues of KRW42,017.3 billion ($31.38 billion) in the first half of 2024, up 8.6% year-on-year, but post-tax profits decreased 2% to KRW2,939.7 billion ($2.2 billion).
Companies - Mon, September 9, 2024 | 8:07 am GMT+7